Bulletin of Latin American Research, 2020 DOI:10.1111/blar.13138
The Deviated Mourning of the
Disappeared: Reimagining
Disappearance and Transcending
its Tropes
GABRIEL GATTI
University of the Basque Country, Spain
JAUME PERIS BLANES
Universitat de València, Spain
Forced disappearance has hindered the development of conventional
forms of mourning, but protocols have gradually emerged, establishing
canonical ways of facing that diffculty, while the concepts of ‘disappear-
ance’ and ‘disappeared’ have been consolidated as effective transnational
categories capable of explaining new forms of social violence. This article
examines how in the new forms of disappearance the manifestations of
mourning systematically deviate from the canon and acquire a complex-
ity that exceeds the established tropes about it. It requires reimagining
the dynamics of mourning in the new contexts of disappearance and,
especially, in those of ‘social disappearance’.
Keywords: forced disappearance, living disappeared, mourning, social
disappearance.
Disappearance, the Disappeared and their Tropes
Today it is hard to fnd anyone who does not know what ‘forced disappearance’ of
persons is or what the fgure of ‘the disappeared’ represents. The naturalisation of
these concepts is a recent phenomenon, however, dating back to 2006, when the United
Nations General Assembly adopted the International Convention for the Protection of
All Persons from Enforced Disappearance. This milestone marks the beginning of a new
phase in the history of the concepts of ‘disappearance’ and ‘disappeared’, the stage of
agreed-on and established names. Both concepts, until then ambiguous, uncertain, open,
have since become solid and frm. First, they gained legal effectiveness, as they denote
very diverse situations of human rights violations, enabling not only their visibility
and problematisation, but also the possibility of seeking justice. They then achieved
institutional frmness, as the apparatus associated with them (evaluation committees,
working groups, and a range of forced disappearance specialists such as legal experts,
psychologists, forensic experts, anthropologists, sociologists, and culture scholars)
© 2020 Society for Latin American Studies 1