Effects of substrate bias voltage on mechanical properties and
tribological behaviors of RF sputtered multilayer TiN/CrAlN films
Xiao Chen, Yeting Xi, Jie Meng, Xiaolu Pang, Huisheng Yang
*
School of Materials Science and Engineering, University of Science and Technology Beijing, Beijing 100083, China
article info
Article history:
Received 28 July 2015
Received in revised form
30 September 2015
Accepted 8 October 2015
Available online 22 October 2015
Keywords:
TiN/CrAlN films
RF magnetron sputtering
Substrate bias
Mechanical properties
Tribological properties
abstract
Multilayer brittle TiN/CrAlN films were prepared on polished silicon and high speed steel by RF
magnetron sputtering technology with various substrate bias voltages ranging from 0 to 150 V. In this
study, the main attention is targeting the correlation between the substrate bias voltage and the resulting
mechanicaletribological properties. It is revealed that the films become much denser and more compact
with increasing substrate bias, meanwhile, hardness and elastic modulus are correspondingly elevated.
However, relatively decreased adhesion emerges when reaching the bias voltage of 150 V. The wear
resistance is progressively enhanced while the deposition rate gradually declines as the substrate bias
increases. Additionally, the mean values of dry friction coefficients sliding against Si
3
N
4
are in the range
of 0.57e0.42, and the wear volumes are ranging from 23.97 10
3
to 13.93 10
3
mm
3
. Thus, it can be
drawn that the film maintains more excellent mechanical and tribological properties, which is sputtered
at the moderate substrate bias of 100 V.
© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
In this day and age, to protect the cutting tool surface and
prolong the service life, transition metal nitride films have been
prevalently used in the modern machining industry such as TiN,
CrN, TiAlN films, which are attributed to their attractive properties
such as oxidation resistance, high hardness, good wear resistance
and low friction coefficient [1e5]. However, as modern industry
rapidly and dramatically develops, practical operating environ-
ments are gradually becoming much sterner including higher
temperature and faster cutting speed. Thus, compared with con-
ventional metal nitride films, the protected CrAlN multilayer films
come into being due to more excellent performances such as su-
perior mechanical and tribology properties [6e11]. Currently, an
increasing amount of studies have focused on CrAlN multilayer
films, which are promising to achieve a widespread applications in
the high speed machining of cutting tools because the aluminum
and chromium elements can produce complex oxides, which are
considered an effective barrier of oxygen diffusion inward. Will-
mann et al. [12] illustrated that CrAlN films obtain high thermal
stability over 900
C in ambient atmosphere, which are ascribed to
the formation of complex oxides (Cr, Al)
2
O
3
.
CrAlN multilayer films can be prepared by means of physical
vapor deposition techniques, such as cathodic arc ion plating
[13,14], beam plasma-assisted physical vapor deposition [15] and
unbalanced reactive magnetron sputtering [16,17]. In order to
optimize the properties, numerous researchers have tried to tailor
Cr/Al atom ratio and alter the deposition parameters such as total
working pressure and substrate bias voltage. Several studies [18,19]
have confirmed that the Al content in the Cr
(1x)
Al
x
N films is
limited at x ¼ 0.6e0.7, obtaining more excellent performances.
Additionally, CrAlN films exhibit great tribological properties up to
500
C [20]. Spain et al. [21] confirmed that the service life of CrAlN
films can be prolonged by 8/3 times than TiN films. R. Escobar
Galindo et al. [22] argued that adding TiN layer into multilayer
CrAlN film, acting as an effective oxygen diffusion barrier layer
reducing the inward diffusion, can promote the aluminium-rich
oxides formation on the surface, thus enhancing the long-time
oxidation resistance of the film. Meanwhile, multilayer system
can enhance the adhesion. Therefore, TiN/CrAlN multilayer system
is chosen in this study.
As is well known, the structure and properties of multilayer
films are strongly relying on the deposition conditions. Particularly,
substrate bias voltage is an essential sputtered parameter which
apparently influences the quality of the films due to the strong
strength of adatom mobility and ion bombardment effect. The
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: hsyang@263.net (H. Yang).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Alloys and Compounds
journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jalcom
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2015.10.076
0925-8388/© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Journal of Alloys and Compounds 665 (2016) 210e217