r
’s Gravesande’s Foundations
for Mechanics
Steffen Ducheyne and Jip van Besouw
Centre for Logic and Philosophy of Science, Vrije
Universiteit Brussel, Brussels, Belgium
Related Topics
’ s Gravesande · Foundations of mechanics · Vis
viva controversy
Introduction
This entry deals with foundational issues in the
mechanics of ’ s Gravesande. First, it deals with
how he defined the fundamental concepts of his
mechanics. Second, it looks at his use of the
concept “force” and his intervention in the vis
viva controversy.
The first part of this entry examines W.J. ’ s
Gravesande’ s views on space, time, body, and
force and is based on the various editions of his
Elements and Institutions, and his 1722 “Essay”
(These works refer to Mathematical elements of
physics confirmed by experiments, its abridgment,
Institutions of Newtonian philosophy , and “Essay
on a new theory of the collision of bodies.” See
“Works cited.” For contextualization of ’ s
Gravesande’ s natural philosophy, his specific
way of appropriating Newton’ s natural-
philosophical work, and his early career, see
Ducheyne (2014a, b) and Van Besouw (2016).).
In all three editions of the Elements, “place”
(locus) is defined by ’ s Gravesande as the space
(spatium) occupied by a body. (In this and the
following quotations, one finds clear parallels
with the following sentences from Newton’ s scho-
lium on space and time: “Absolute, true, and
mathematical time, in and of itself and of its own
nature, without reference to anything external,
flows uniformly [...]. Relative, apparent, and
common time is any sensible and external mea-
sure (precise or imprecise) of duration by means
of motion [...]. [...] Absolute space, of its own
nature without reference to anything external,
always remains homogeneous and immovable.
Relative space is any movable measure or dimen-
sion of this absolute space; such a measure or
dimension is determined by our senses from the
situation [per situm] of the space with respect to
bodies [...]. [...] Place is the part of space that a
body occupies, and it is, depending on the space,
either absolute of relative [...].” (1999: 408–409).
Note however that ’ s Gravesande applies the
adjectives absolute and relative to place rather
than to space.) Place and time can be absolute or
relative. Throughout these works, ’ s Gravesande
defines true or absolute place as “a part of immo-
bile space, which is occupied by a body”; relative
place, “which can only be distinguished by the
senses,” as the position (situs) of a body with
respect to other bodies; true or absolute time as
having “no relation to the motion of bodies, nor to
the succession of ideas in an intelligent Being”
and as flowing “always equally by its nature”; and
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020
D. Jalobeanu, C. T. Wolfe (eds.), Encyclopedia of Early Modern Philosophy and the Sciences,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-20791-9_40-1