International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 07 Issue: 06 | June 2020 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
© 2020, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 4884
COMPARATIVE STUDY ON DIFFERENTIAL AXIAL SHORTENING IN TALL
STRUCTURES USING ACI CODE AND EUROCODE-2
Krish A. Mandavia
1
, Prof. Deepak R. Tarachandani
2
1
Post Graduate Student, Applied Mechanics Department, L.D. College of Engineering, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India
2
Associate Professor, Applied Mechanics Department, L.D. College of Engineering, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India
---------------------------------------------------------------------***----------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - With increasing height of structures, the effect of
column shortening, both elastic and non-elastic, take on added
significance and need distinct consideration in design and
construction. Axial shortening in tall buildings would be of
little concern if all vertical elements shorten equally. However,
vertical members such as walls and columns may shorten in
different amounts due to different service axial stress. Axial
shortening depends on number of parameters such as type of
concrete, environmental conditions, and the rate and sequence
of construction. Thus, it’s a difficult task to determine the exact
value of axial shortening. This study is concerned with
predicting of differential axial shortening by comparing two
standards: ACI 209R-92 and Eurocode-2 (British Standards)
for tall structures with different number of stories (40,60 and
80). Also, the effect of parameters such as construction
sequence, rate of loading and type of concrete are considered.
The analysis of the structures is carried using ETABS and
results obtained from this study gives idea about different
effects of changing parameters for different standards.
Key Words: Differential Axial Shortening (DAS),
Construction Sequence, Creep and Shrinkage of
Concrete, ETABS
1. INTRODUCTION
In tall buildings, columns carry massive loads which
effectively compress the column along its axis. This can be
commonly referred to as ‘axial shortening’. Differential axial
shortening (DAS) for gravity load bearing components in tall
buildings is a phenomenon which was first noticed in the
1960’s with the use of concrete in combination with
reinforcing steel in tall buildings. As buildings increased by
height, elastic shortening became apparent during
construction, and methods for correcting of instantaneous
shortening such as construction of each floor to a corrected
level or datum, became more common practice.
The components of column shortening are the elastic
shortening and the inelastic shortening due to creep and
shrinkage. Analysis of column shortening may be viewed as
an application of long‐term analysis of concrete structures.
The method of quantification of axial shortening of
reinforced concrete columns was originally introduced by
Fintel and Khan (1969) and this method was further refined
by Ghosh (1996). A widely used method for predicting
column shortening in a tall building is the method proposed
by Fintel et al. (1987) and published by Portland Cement
Association (PCA).
Reliable shrinkage and creep material models for concrete
has been an area of research interest for many years and
there are several well-established empirical relationships
between these long-term strains and the various properties
of concrete. Among them are several popular models with an
increasing number of factors to be considered such as the B3
(Bazant and Baweja 2000) model and simple but popular
models like the ACI 209, EC2 (BSI 2004) and GL2000
(Gardner and Lockman 2001) method. The time dependent
strain components of concrete considered in these material
models are as given in Table 1.
Table 1. Components for Different Models
Features ACI 209R EC-2
Basic Creep
Drying Creep
Autogenous
Shrinkage
Drying Shrinkage
The main objective of research are
1. To predict the effects of differential shortening in
tall buildings and addressing them through design
and construction.
2. To provide guidelines by comparing different
standards available to calculate time dependent
properties.
2. MODELING IN SOFTWARE
The following was applied to reach the above objectives:
1. The present study was carried out for 40-story
building with moment resisting frame + shear wall
core, 60-story building with outrigger system and
tube system, each and 80-story building with
outrigger system and tube system, each.
2. These structural systems were analyzed using
ETABS (v17) software. Both elastic and inelastic
shortening were calculated using sequential
analysis.