Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Research in International Business and Finance
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ribaf
Full length Article
Stock market reactions to domestic sentiment: Panel CS-ARDL
evidence
Walid M.A. Ahmed
Department of Business Administration, Faculty of Business, Ain Shams University, P.O. Box 11566, Cairo, Egypt
ARTICLEINFO
JEL classification:
C52
F14
G12
Q43
Keywords:
Business sentiment
Consumer sentiment
Dynamic h
Dynamic heterogeneous panels
Cross-sectional dependence
Cross-sectionally augmented ARDL
ABSTRACT
This study sets out to explore the efects of business and consumer sentiment on stock market
performance, within the separate contexts of advanced and emerging markets. The empirical
analysis is carried out using the cross-sectionally augmented autoregressive distributed lag (CS-
ARDL) modeling approach, which considers time dynamics, cross-sectional heterogeneity, and
cross-sectional dependence. The fndings fordevelopedmarketssuggestthatbusinesssentiment
haspositiveleadingefectsonstockreturns,acrossshort-andlong-termtimehorizons,while for
emerging markets, the price impact of business sentiment turns out to be short-lived. On the
other hand, consumer sentiment tends to afect positively both market types, albeit only in the
shortrun.Furthermore,theinfuenceofsentimentindicatorsseemstobestrongerinemerging-
than in developed-market countries. The results remain robust, even after controlling for a rich
rangeofpotentialpredictorsofstockreturns.Generally,suchevidencehighlightstherelevance
of psychological factors, such as business and consumer sentiment, in determining the future
trajectory of asset prices.
1. Introduction
In a world of market imperfections and growing uncertainty, agents’ sentiment about future economic trends continues to be a
vitalcomponentofbusinessand fnancialanalysis.People’sdecisionstoconsume,save,orinvesttendto feedontheirexpectations
with respect to economic performance in the near term, particularly in the absence of reliable information on underlying funda-
mentals. For instance, if consumers are upbeat (downbeat) about their fnances, they are likely to spend more (less) and save less
(more).Similarly,ifproducersandbusinessownersfeeloptimistictowardstheeconomyandbusinessprospects,theywillbemore
motivated to hire, invest, and expand, which perhaps ultimately contribute to stimulating employment, production, and economic
growth.Incontrast,apervasivemoodofpessimismamongbusinessleadersandprofessionalscouldcastalingeringshadowonfuture
economicactivity. Batchelor(2001) arguesthatifhouseholdsandbusinesseshaverationalperceptionsandexpectations,highlevels
of consumer and business confdence indicators are more probable to augur well for economic growth. Nevertheless, this is not
suggestiveofamereunidirectionallinkbetweenprevailingconfdencelevelsandmacroeconomic fundamentals,sincethevagariesof
economic cycles and fuctuations do impinge on market sentiment
Aspointedoutby Barberisetal.(1998) and Chauetal.(2016),amongothers,sentimentrefectsthegeneralattitudethatagents
(e.g.,consumers,producers,investors)holdtowardsaparticularasset,industry,market,ortheoverallhealthofaneconomy.Such
attitudes can have grave implications for economic activity and fnancial market developments. In reality, investors, analysts, and
regulators are increasingly attentive to the information content of market sentiment indices, since these survey-based leading
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ribaf.2020.101240
Received8April2019;Receivedinrevisedform23April2020;Accepted9May2020
E-mail address: wmaziz@commerce.asu.edu.eg.
Research in International Business and Finance 54 (2020) 101240
Available online 26 May 2020
0275-5319/ © 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T