Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Engineering Structures
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/engstruct
Fibre beam element models for nonlinear analysis of concentrically loaded
circular CFT columns considering the size effect
Siqi Lin
a
, Yan-Gang Zhao
a,b
, Zhao-Hui Lu
a,
⁎
a
Key Laboratory of Urban Security and Disaster Engineering of Ministry of Education, Beijing University of Technology, Beijing 100124, China
b
Dept. of Architecture and Building Engineering, Kanagawa Univ., Kanagawa 2218686, Japan
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Fibre beam element model
Concrete-filled steel tube columns
Size effect
ABSTRACT
The fibre beam element (FBE) method has been widely used to investigate the behaviors of concrete-filled steel
tube (CFT) columns for its high efficiency and accuracy. The existing models were generally developed or ca-
librated by using specimens with relatively small size, in which the size effects were ignored or poorly in-
corporated. Additionally, most existing FBE models focused on CFT stub columns. In this paper, a new FBE
model for nonlinear analysis of concentrically loaded stub and slender columns was proposed, in which the size
effects on the effective stress-strain relationships of steel tube and core concrete were well incorporated. The
proposed FBE models were then used to develop an ultimate strength model for the design of both stub and
slender columns. A total of 1029 specimens assembled from 72 previous studies were used to verify the proposed
models. The results suggested that the proposed FBE model performs quite well for both small- and large- size
CFT stub columns and predicts the behaviors of slender columns with reasonable accuracy. Moreover, the ul-
timate strength model developed based on the proposed FBE models was found to make satisfying prediction of
test results.
1. Introduction
Concrete-filled steel tube (CFT) columns, as composite structures,
combine the advantages of the constituent steel and concrete materials
[1], leading to excellent performance of high strength, stiffness and
ductility [2]. To understand the behaviours of CFT columns, many ex-
perimental tests have been done in previous studies. Although experi-
mental tests are important for the investigation of CFT columns, they
are generally expensive and time-consuming. The finite element
method is an alternative way to investigate the behaviours of CFT
columns. Detailed three-dimensional (3D) finite-element (FE) models
using commercial software, e.g. ABAQUS, allow direct modelling of the
composite action between the steel and concrete components, with
local and global imperfections, residual stresses and boundary condi-
tions considered [3]. In general, 3D FE models can precisely predict the
behaviour of composite structures, which, however, are tedious and
complicated to build and impractical for the analysis of large structural
systems or for routine design [4]. To achieve a balance between effi-
ciency and accuracy, the fibre beam element (FBE) method was widely
used for its accuracy and high computational efficiency [5].
For the FBE method, effective stress-strain models of steel tube and
concrete, accounting for the composite effects, are necessary. Several
effective stress-strain models have been available in previous studies for
nonlinear analysis of concentrically loaded CFT columns, which were
mainly developed based on experimental test results, e.g., the models of
Neogi et al. [6],Sato [7],Tang et al. [8], Susantha et al. [9], Han et al.
[10], Sakino et al. [11], Chen et al. [12], Hatzigeorgiou [13], and De-
navit [5], or based on regression analysis of the effective stress-strain
curves generated using 3D FE models, e.g., Shams et al. [14], Lai et al.
[15], and Katwal et al. [4]. For the models developed based on ex-
perimental tests, their accuracy was generally limited to the range of
tests used. Using 3D FE method to develop FBE models, i.e., the effec-
tive stress-strain models of steel tube and concrete, is considered more
reliable and scientific [4]. Among existing FBE models, Katwal et al.’s,
developed based on Tao et al.’s 3D FE model [3], was one of the most
sophisticated for that the strain softening or strain-hardening behaviour
of steel tube and concrete were well simulated. Generally, the results
predicted by Katwal et al.’s model agreed well with experimental re-
sults. However, the specimens they used to verify their model generally
had relatively small size, which is a common issue for all existing FBE
models. It is well known that the CFT columns in practical structures
are of large size, and their behaviours have been found to differ from
those of small-size specimens [16–18]. Thus, the applicability of ex-
isting FBE models to large-size CFT columns is doubtful. Although some
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engstruct.2020.110400
Received 17 September 2019; Received in revised form 16 January 2020; Accepted 17 February 2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: luzhaohui@bjut.edu.cn (Z.-H. Lu).
Engineering Structures 210 (2020) 110400
0141-0296/ © 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T