Delayed Pulmonary Edema and Bronchospasm
After Accidental Lacrimator Exposure
FEDERICO E. VACA, MD, JOHN H. MYERS, MD,
MARK LANGDORF, MD, MHPE
Clinical manifestations of lacrimator exposure can be immediate or
significantly delayed. In both phases, the sequelae can be severe and
life-threatening. As personal protection devices, these agents have
become readily available to the public in many areas of the country.
Emergency physicians should gain a firm understanding of the presenta-
tion, management, and disposition of the lacrimator-exposed patient. A
case of accidental prolonged lacrimator exposure inducing pulmonary
edema and bronchospesm is presented. (Am J Emerg Med 1996;14:402-
405. Copyright © 1996 by W.B. Saunders Company)
Lacrimators are a group of chemical agents used for riot
control by law enforcement agencies throughout the US.
Increasingly, civilians are carrying personal protection de-
vices that also contain these chemical agents. We describe
the case of a young woman who presented to our emergency
department (ED) with delayed-onset pulmonary edema and
severe bronchospasm after a prolonged accidental exposure
to chloroacetophenone (CN) dispensed from a personal
protection device. We will review the most commonly used
lacrimating agents and their potential clinical sequelae.
Emergency physicians must be aware of the complications
resulting from exposure to these agents.
CASE REPORT
A 24-year-old Vietnamese woman was brought to our ED by
paramedics with a chief complaint of chest pain and shortness of
breath of 3 hours' duration. The paramedics reported that they
found the patient diaphoretic, profoundly orthopneic, and holding
her chest. Additionally, she complained of a bitter taste in her
mouth. She denied fever, nausea, emesis, hernoptysis, or history of
tuberculosis. She had a history of rheumatic heart disease and a St.
Jude mitral valve replacement in July 1991. Her medications
included warfarin and iron.
Initial physical examination found a thin woman in obvious
respiratory distress. She was alert and awake, holding her chest,
sitting upright with labored respirations, and answered questions
appropriately with assistance of a Vietnamese translator. Her blood
pressure was 90/60 mm Hg, her pulse rate was 100 beats/min,
respiration rate was 20 breaths/rain, and oral temperature was
37.4°C. Her saturation by pulse oximetry was 94% on 4 liters of
oxygen via nasal cannula.
The pupils were equal and reactive. There was mild epiphoria
with scleral and subconjunctival injection bilaterally. No jugular
venous distention or carotid bruits were appreciated. Her point of
maximal impulse (PMI) was normal with a regular tachycardia and
a mechanical S1 click. There was a nonradiating II/VI systolic
murmur at the left sternal border, with no audible rub or gallop. The
lungs had bilateral rales with mild to moderate expiratory wheezes.
The remainder of the physical examination was unremarkable.
An electrocardiogram showed sinus tachycardia with right atrial
enlargement. The initial arterial blood gas consisted of a pH of
7.39, PCO2 of 33.5, PO2of 75.8, HCO3 of 20.2, and Sat of 95.2% on
4 liters of oxygen. The prothrombin time was 14.7 and partial
thromboplastin time PTT was 34.3. A portable chest radiograph
was obtained with a preliminary reading of cardiogenic pulmonary
edema (Figure 1).
The patient was treated aggressively in the ED with diuretics and
nitroglycerine. She was also heparinized because, initially, coro-
nary thrombosis was highly suspected. A cardiology consultation
was obtained. An echocardiogram revealed normal left ventricular
size and function with mild mitral and tricuspid regurgitation. The
patient improved minimally with the initial interventions. Consulta-
tion with our expert chest radiologist was obtained. It was
immediately recognized that the chest X-ray showed many charac-
teristics of inhalation injury lung edema, including unilaterally
worsened edema and increased vascular markings.
On further questioning, the patient reported that her roommate,
the wife of a security officer, had sprayed what she thought was
"room deodorizer" throughout the small apartment 18 hours
before the onset of symptoms. She recalled a burning sensation in
her eyes as well as tearing. The cannister was obtained and
determined to contain chloroacetophenone (CN), a potent lacrima-
tor designed to cause eye and upper respiratory inflammation and
irritation to deter attackers when sprayed in close proximity.
The patient was subsequently admitted to the intensive care unit
ICU with a diagnosis of inhalation pneumonitis with delayed
noncardiogenic pulmonary edema. At that time, it was believed that
the already compromised cardiovascular status of the patient was
significantly worsened by the prolonged lacrimator exposure and
subsequent lung injury. During her hospital course, her symptoms
gradually improved over 2 to 3 days. However, several days after
admission, her respiratory status deteriorated and she was noted to
have worsening pulmonary edema. The cardiothoracic surgery
consultant recommended that the patient undergo mitral valve
replacement. The procedure was performed and the patient toler-
ated the surgery well. She was discharged without further complica-
tions.
From the Division of Emergency Medicine, University of California
Irvine Medical Center, Orange, CA.
Manuscript received April 4, 1995, returned May 15, 1995; revision
received July 1,1995, accepted July 17, 1995.
Address reprint requests to Dr Vaca, 3545 Caminito El Rincon
#235, San Diego, CA92130.
Key Words: Lacrimators, pulmonary edema, chloroacetophenone,
o-chlorobenzylidenemalononitrile, chloropicrin, capsaicin.
Copyright © 1996 by W.B. Saunders Company
0735-6757/96/1404-001755.00/0
402
DISCUSSION
Lacrimating agents are solid chemicals dispensed as a fine
dust or aerosol spray. They are used by law enforcement
agencies for riot control, but are being used with increasing
frequency by civilians in small personal protection devices.
These devices are commonly referred to as tear gas, mace,
and more recently, "pepper spray." Lacrimators create
several desired effects that temporarily incapacitate the