Africa Journal of Business Management Vol. 4(17), pp. 3697-3707, 4 December, 2010
Available online at http://www.academicjournals.org/AJBM
ISSN 1993-8233 ©2010 Academic Journals
Full Length Research Paper
Component and process commonalities in production
system under various uncertain factors
M. A. Wazed
1,2
*, S. Ahmed
1
and Y. Nukman
1
1
Department of Engineering Design and Manufacture, University of Malaya (UM) 50603 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
2
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Chittagong University of Engineering and Technology (CUET),
Chittagong 4349, Bangladesh.
Accepted 19 May, 2010
In this paper, the authors studied the effects of process and component/part commonality and
uncertain factors (viz. lead time, machine breakdown etc.) on deliverable parameters of a multi product,
multi-period and multistage dependent demand manufacturing environment. The throughput of finished
products and average production time of the system are examined for various experimental scenarios
on the basis of existing manufacturing setup of a company consisting of multiple end products.
Simulation package, namely WITNESS is used to simulate/analyze the situations of the production lines.
Simulation models are developed, verified and validated with the historical data from the company. It is
found that inclusion of common components in manufacturing system is always beneficial over the
non-commonality environment, especially i) in uncertain situations, ii) for long procurement lead time of
components and iii) when the number of parts increase in the system. Impacts of machine breakdown
on system outcomes are higher than that of the lead time variation. The combination of uncertain
factors has more impact on outcomes (throughput and average production time) compared to the
individual factor. Commonality has a better control over the machine breakdown than lead time
uncertainty. Component commonality is more effective for a production environment under uncertain
situations than the process commonality.
Key words: Commonality, simulation, witness.
INTRODUCTION
Component commonality refers to a manufacturing
environment where two or more products use the same
components in their assembly. Commonality is an
integral element of the increasingly popular assemble-to-
order strategy that inventories certain critical components
–typically, with long lead time and expensive - in a
generic form (Mirchandani and Mishra, 2002). Commona-
lity is an approach in manufacturing, production and
inventory management system where different
components replace by common component(s) or same
components are used for multiple products. It simplifies
the management and control of resources and eases the
analysis. Commonality helps to improve the existing product
*Corresponding author. E-mail: awazed@gmail.com.
/process or to develop a new product/process at an
optimize costs. The authors would like to humbly refer the
readers to Wazed et al. (2010a) for the big picture of the
commonality and for its state-of-the-art.
Multi-stage production planning is a system which
transforms or transfers inventories through a set of
connected stages to produce finished goods. This system
may contain stages which represent the delivery or
transformation of raw materials, the transfer of work-in-
process between production facilities, the assembly of
component parts, or the distribution of finished goods.
The fundamental challenge of multi-stage production is
the propagation and accumulation of uncertainties, which
influences the conformity of the outputs (Du and Chen,
2000).
Machine breakdown means the failure or stoppage of
machine(s) for unknown reason(s) and a representation of