Journal of Public Policy & Marketing
Vol. 30 (1) Spring 2011, 14–22
© 2011, American Marketing Association
ISSN: 0743-9156 (print), 1547-7207 (electronic) 14
Transforming Consumer Health
Debra L. Scammon, Punam A. Keller, Pia A. Albinsson,
Shalini Bahl, Jesse R. Catlin, Kelly L. Haws, Jeremy Kees,
Tracey King, Elizabeth Gelfand Miller, Ann M. Mirabito,
Paula C. Peter, and Robert M. Schindler
The 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act is intended to transform the U.S. health care
system. Its success will require the transformation of consumers’ views about health and their
willingness to participate in healthful behaviors. Focusing on three barriers to consumers’ engagement
in healthful behaviors, the authors review the research literature and suggest opportunities for further
research. Using a social marketing perspective, they suggest actions for health care providers,
marketers, and policy makers to help overcome these barriers.
Keywords: understanding, decision making, health maintenance, engagement, activation
Debra L. Scammon is Emma Eccles Jones Professor of Marketing,
University of Utah (e-mail: Debra. Scammon@business.utah.edu).
Punam A. Keller is Professor of Marketing, Dartmouth College (e-mail:
Punam.Keller@tuck.dartmouth.edu). Pia A. Albinsson is Assistant
Professor of Marketing, Appalachian State University (e-mail:
albinssonpa@ appstate.edu). Shalini Bahl is Principal Consultant,
iAM Business Consulting (e-mail: shalini@iam-bc.com). Jesse R.
Catlin is a doctoral student, University of California, Irvine (e-mail:
jcatlin@uci.edu). Kelly L. Haws is Assistant Professor of Marketing,
Texas A&M University (e-mail: khaws@mays.tamu.edu). Jeremy Kees
is Assistant Professor of Marketing, Villanova University (e-mail: jkees@
villanova.edu). Tracey King is Assistant Professor of Marketing, Ameri-
can University (e-mail: traceyk@ american.edu). Elizabeth Gelfand
Miller is Assistant Professor of Marketing, Boston College (e-mail:
milleliz@ bc.edu). Ann M. Mirabito is Assistant Professor of Marketing,
Baylor University (e-mail: Ann_Mirabito@baylor.edu). Paula C. Peter is
Assistant Professor of Marketing, San Diego State University (e-mail:
ppeter@ mail.sdsu.edu). Robert M. Schindler is Professor of Market-
ing, Rutgers University–Camden (e-mail: rschindl@ camden. rutgers.
edu). Debra Scammon and Punam Keller cochaired the General
Health track at the 2009 Transformative Consumer Research Con-
ference at Villanova University and led the development of this
essay. The other authors, listed alphabetically, all participated in the
conference and contributed equally to the essay.
T
he Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (2010),
signed into law March 2010, brings the United States
closer to universal health coverage than ever before.
Implicit in the new law is the assumption that consumers
will willingly participate in a variety of health care initia-
tives, from choosing health care providers on the basis of
the quality of care they provide to participating in preven-
tive care to stay healthy. The success of this new law will
require innovative public policies and initiatives aimed at
changing consumers’ views about health and enhancing
their motivation and ability to participate in healthful
behaviors.
We believe that existing and new research on consumer
health behavior will be a valuable aid in this endeavor. We
focus on three barriers that undermine consumer health:
(1) understanding health information, (2) making healthful
decision , and (3) maintaining healthful behaviors. For each
barrier, we note relevant literature and suggest opportuni-
ties for further transformative research. We also provide
suggestions for health care providers and marketers to help
support transformed consumer behaviors and recommenda-
tions for public policy that could help overcome the barriers
(Table 1).
Transformative consumer researchers apply marketing
techniques and tools to enhance individual and collective
well-being (Mick 2006). We advocate a social marketing
approach for segmenting consumers and identifying the
challenges that each segment faces (Andreasen 2006). As
the Health Belief Model (Becker 1974) outlines, identifying
consumer barriers is a key determinant for changing health
behavior. In the current article, we use our combined
research knowledge and the research literature on consumer
health behaviors to identify three key barriers. The primary
focus in on individual consumer barriers, but we also iden-
tify needed changes in health care provider (hereinafter,
provider) behavior in addition to social and policy initia-
tives that support individual behavior change.
Barrier 1: Consumer Understanding of
Health Information and Actions
For consumers to become more engaged in managing their
own health, they must have the knowledge, skills, and con-
fidence to understand health information and the impact of
their behaviors on their health and well-being. Consumers
may not recognize, and may even deny, the relationship