Original Communication
Appreciation at Work
in the Swiss Armed Forces
Désirée Stocker
1
, Nicola Jacobshagen
2
, Norbert K. Semmer
2
, and Hubert Annen
3
1
University of Bern, Switzerland,
2
University of Bern and Swiss Centre for Affective Sciences, Geneva,
Switzerland,
3
Swiss Military Academy at ETH Zurich, Switzerland
Swiss Journal of Psychology, 69 (2), 2010, 117–124
DOI 10.1024/1421-0185.a000013
Abstract. This study explores the impact of appreciation at work among military professionals. Based on the concept of “Stress-as-Of-
fense-to-Self” (Semmer, Jacobshagen, Meier, & Elfering, 2007), appreciation is a possible resource due to boosts to self-esteem. We
measured appreciation at work with a scale differentiating several forms and sources of appreciation. Data were gathered by an online
survey of 228 male career officers and career noncommissioned officers of the Swiss Armed Forces. Appreciation at work correlated
positively with job satisfaction and negatively with feelings of resentment. Moreover, appreciation at work explained incremental variance
over and above job control, social support, and interactional justice. These results underline its distinction from other resource variables.
Legal employment conditions of the military professionals include working hours in accordance with ongoing requirements without upper
limits established. Moderator analysis showed that appreciation buffered the effect of long working hours on job satisfaction. Furthermore,
appreciation mediated the effect of illegitimate tasks on job satisfaction as well as on feelings of resentment. Overall, these findings imply
that it is worth building an organisational culture based on appreciation at work. Implications for research and military training are
discussed.
Keywords: stress, appreciation, military working conditions, moderation, mediation
Introduction
What a pleasure! Your boss congratulates you on a pro-
ject well-done. Or one of your colleagues shows gratitude
for your support. We all know the delight stemming from
the appreciation that we receive at work. It gives us the
feeling of being acknowledged and likely encourages us
to work even harder. Herzberg (1974) was among the first
to recognise that appreciation enhances motivation and
job satisfaction. However, despite this early recognition,
only little research has been done since on this issue. In
the effort-reward model by Siegrist (1996), appreciation
is one of the three reward factors along with money and
job security/career opportunities, and findings by Van
Vegchel, De Jonge, Bakker, and Schaufeli (2002) suggest
that it is the most important one. A recent study has
shown that young workers experienced higher job satis-
faction if appreciation was high over the course of four
years (Elfering, Semmer, Tschan, Kälin, & Bucher,
2007). Yet, the few scales measuring appreciation tend to
be rather general (e.g., Siegrist, 1996; Yukl, 2002).
Hence, questions about sources, forms, aspects, circum-
stances, and effects of appreciation at work remain unan-
swered by scientific research.
Generally, appreciation relates to evaluation by others
(Semmer & Jacobshagen, 2003) and is closely connected
to self-esteem (Harter, 1993). Most people want to
achieve a positive evaluation in order to protect their self-
esteem (Baumeister, 1996). Consequently, a threat to self-
esteem may provoke the experience of stress. According
to the “Stress-as-Offense-to-Self” concept (SOS; Semmer,
Jacobshagen, Meier, & Elfering, 2007), the threat to the
self is seen as a core element of many stress experiences.
Lack of appreciation constitutes such a threat; it may man-
ifest itself not only in dismissive behaviour, but also in
“illegitimate tasks” (Semmer, Tschan, Meier, Facchin, &
Jacobshagen, 2010). Illegitimate tasks are tasks that are
perceived as unreasonable or unnecessary, as not being
part of one’s professional role, thus violating expectations
about what can reasonably be required of a given person.
On the other hand, appreciation “boosts” self-esteem and
is therefore regarded as an important cause of well-being
and a powerful resource in the context of stress (Semmer
et al., 2007). Although the role of appreciation is hardly
disputed, to our knowledge no scale exists that goes be-
yond only mentioning appreciation in general as part of
other constructs (such as leadership) to also focus on ap-
preciation and distinguish between the various forms in
which it is communicated. The present study is the first to
report results obtained with such a scale.
There are several sources of stress for Swiss military
professionals. For instance, the employment conditions of
officers and noncommissioned officers [Unteroffiziere]
Swiss J. Psychol. 69 (2) © 2010 by Verlag Hans Huber, Hogrefe AG, Bern