ABSTRACT: The transformations of tristearin were examined
by modulated temperature differential scanning calorimetry
(MTDSC) in order to study the effect of operational parameters
on the nature of information obtained from this technique. Tris-
tearin has been used as a model polymorphic system showing
metastable phases and complicated transformation routes oc-
curring at relatively slow rates. The parameters examined were
underlying heating/cooling rates and the amplitude of modula-
tion. The first conclusion is that MTDSC enables overlapping α-
melting and β-crystallization events to be separated, thus in-
creasing the information obtained compared to normal thermal
analysis. Other general conclusions are that observation of re-
versible processes is strongly influenced by the underlying heat-
ing rate; low to moderate heating rates are recommended. Am-
plitude of modulation has a complicated effect on the phenom-
enon being studied; when studying systems that exhibit
metastable or polymorphic transitions, it is recommended that
a range of amplitudes be tested to enable confirmation of
whether an observed “recrystallization” effect is a new phase or
the same phase as the one melting. Cooling with modulation
disturbs the crystallization process, possibly leading to smaller
or imperfect crystals; however, the phases obtained are not dif-
ferent compared to normal DSC. The usefulness of MTDSC in
analyzing these types of complicated systems is primarily quali-
tative at the moment. Some recommendations have been made
as to the combinations of parameters for studying such systems.
Paper no. J8832 in JAOCS 76, 499–505 (April 1999)
KEY WORDS: Differential scanning calorimetry, metastable
forms, MTDSC, modulated temperature, oscillating, phase be-
havior, polymorphism, triglycerides, tristearin.
Lipids are important excipients in the pharmaceutical industry,
finding use as matrix formers, binders, lubricants, etc. The major
components of these commercial excipients obtained from nat-
ural fats are blends of triglycerides. Pure monoacid triglycerides
can serve as simple models for studying these blends.
The physical properties of triglycerides are mostly deter-
mined by their complex polymorphism. Generally, triglyc-
erides exhibit three different polymorphic forms character-
ized by particular chain packing and thermal stability: alpha
(α), beta-prime (β′), and beta (β). The transformations are
monotropic and theoretically take place from α to β′ to β (1).
The different polymorphic forms of triglycerides have
been extensively studied (1–6), and the transformations are
summarized in Figure 1. The melt crystallizes primarily into
the α form on cooling, although special thermal treatment or
very slow cooling can lead to the formation of the β′ or β
form, respectively (7,8). The transformation from the
metastable α form to the most stable β form may occur in the
solid state through aging of the α form at temperatures below
its melting point. Heating the α form slowly can also lead to
its transformation to the β form; the amount or extent of β′
formation during this process depends on the fatty acid chain-
length. The existence of two (or even more) forms of the β′
form is debated as to whether there are two distinct phases (7)
or whether the β′
2
consists simply of imperfect β′ crystals (8).
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) is a powerful tool
in the study of the polymorphic transformations in these sub-
stances (5,8). The recently developed technique of modulated
temperature DSC (MTDSC), also known as modulated DSC
or oscillating DSC, has been cited as having several advan-
tages in this area (9). These include the ability to improve sep-
aration of reversible and irreversible thermal events (over the
time scale of the experimental parameters), and improved res-
olution of closely occurring or overlapping events. The theo-
retical background of this technique has been presented else-
where (9,10) and is briefly summarized below.
Crystallization of a stable phase from a liquid can be re-
garded as a reversible event at the equilibrium temperature.
Melting of a metastable phase is normally an irreversible
Copyright © 1999 by AOCS Press 499 JAOCS, Vol. 76, no. 4 (1999)
*To whom correspondence should be addressed at Pharmacia and Upjohn,
Inc., 7000 Portage Road, Kalamazoo, MI 49001, USA.
E-mail: satish.singh@am.pnu.com
Modulated Temperature Differential Scanning
Calorimetry for Examination of Tristearin Polymorphism:
I. Effect of Operational Parameters
Satish K. Singh
a,
*, Ali Fathe Jalali
b
and Maggie Aldén
b
a
Department of Pharmaceutical Technology, Pharmacia and Upjohn AB, S-751 82 Uppsala, Sweden,
b
Department of Pharmaceutical
Chemistry, Physical and Inorganic Chemistry, Biomedical Center, Uppsala University, S-751 23 Uppsala, Sweden
FIG. 1. Schematic of polymorphic phase transitions in saturated
monoacid triglycerides. Dotted lines represent transitions that occur via
special thermal treatments only. Adapted from Reference 4.