1694 IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN QUANTUM ELECTRONICS, VOL. 15, NO. 6, NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2009
Quantum Logic Circuits and Optical Signal
Generation for a Three-Qubit, Optically
Controlled, Solid-State Quantum Computer
Andrea Del Duce and Polina Bayvel, Senior Member, IEEE
Abstract—We analyze the preparation of an experimental
demonstration for a three-qubit, optically controlled, solid-state
quantum computational system. First, using a genetic program-
ming approach, we design quantum logic circuits, specifically tai-
lored for our computational model, which implement a three-qubit
refined Deutsch–Jozsa algorithm. Aiming at achieving the short-
est possible computational time, we compare two design strategies
based on exploiting two different sets of entangling gates. The first
set comprises fast approximations of controlled-phase gates, while
in the second case, we exploit arbitrary entangling gates with gate
computational times shorter than those of the first set. Then, con-
sidering some recently proposed material implementations of this
quantum computational system, we discuss the generation of the
near-midinfrared, multiwavelength and picosecond optical pulse
sequences necessary for controlling the presented quantum logic
circuits. Finally, we analyze potential sources of errors and assess
the impact of random fluctuations of the parameters controlling
the entangling gates on the overall quantum computational system
performance.
Index Terms—Near-midinfrared picosecond pulse generation,
quantum circuit design, refined Deutsch–Jozsa algorithm, solid-
state quantum computation.
I. INTRODUCTION
A
LTHOUGH during the past years many different proposals
of quantum computational systems have been developed
or even experimentally demonstrated, the task of building a
large-scale quantum computer is still unresolved [1]. One group
of implementations that is believed to have the potential for high
scalability is the one of solid-state quantum computers, which
could benefit from the vast expertise and knowledge acquired
through the successes of classical microelectronics [2], [3].
Among these implementations, Kane’s idea of storing qubits
in the nuclear spin of phosphorus atoms embedded in silicon [4]
has attracted much attention [5]. Although significant break-
throughs have been reported during the past years [6], one of
the challenges of Kane’s proposals lies in the high precision
required for the fabrication techniques of the control electrodes
used for manipulating the qubits [7].
Manuscript received February 19, 2009; revised April 10, 2009. First
published October 20, 2009; current version published December 3, 2009. This
work was supported by the Research Councils U.K. (RCUK) and the Engi-
neering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC), through the Basic
Technology Programme, and by the Royal Society.
The authors are with the Optical Networks Group, Department of Electronic
and Electrical Engineering, University College London (UCL), London WC1E
7JE, U.K. (e-mail: a.delduce@ee.ucl.ac.uk).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/JSTQE.2009.2024326
Building on Kane’s idea, a variation was presented that pro-
posed to exploit, rather than the nuclear spin, the electron spin
of donors [8]. Further, the potential of qubits carried by the elec-
tron spin of donors in semiconductors has been confirmed, for
example, by the results presented in [9], which reported deco-
herence times of up to 60 ms for electron spins of phosphorus
atoms in silicon.
In this paper, we focus on the quantum computation model
proposed by Stoneham et al. [10] that is based on optically
controlled, solid-state quantum logic gates. In this proposal, the
qubits are stored in the spin of electrons from donors in a solid-
state (possibly silicon) substrate. Interactions between two adja-
cent qubits are mediated by a third particle, termed control parti-
cle, placed in their proximity, and are triggered by the excitation
and deexcitation of the control particle through optical pulses.
The strength of this control atom-mediated (CAM) quantum
computation model lies in the optical control of the two-qubit
interactions that allows noisy electrical circuitry to be removed
from the quantum register as well as avoiding high-precision
fabrication processes for placing control electrodes. While it is
expected that patches of up to 20 qubits may be controlled with
this system, scalable quantum registers may then be built by
interconnecting different patches [11]. In [12], these gates were
referred to as SFG gates, since they were first presented in the
paper by Stoneham, Fisher, and Greenland [10]. For generality,
they are referred to as CAM gates throughout this paper, even
though the technology and interaction mechanism is the same.
The quantum computation model based on CAM gates has
been studied intensively during the past years, both, theoretically
and experimentally. The details on the dynamics of the CAM
quantum gate are described in [13], which also compared how
accurately this model was able to produce two-qubit entangling
gates typically used in literature, such as the controlled-phase or
the
√
SWAP gates. In [12], these studies were further developed
and results were presented that aimed at identifying gate param-
eters able to produce, both, highly accurate and fast two-qubit
entangling gates. From the experimental point of view, important
measurements of the lifetimes of two control particle candidates
in a silicon substrate have been recently reported [14]. These re-
sults represent essential steps toward the implementation of a
quantum computer based on CAM gates that lead the way to an
experimental demonstration of a complete few-qubit quantum
computation prototype.
Here, we work toward this aim by analyzing the prepara-
tion of an experimental demonstration of a three-qubit quantum
computation prototype based on the CAM model. Particularly,
1077-260X/$26.00 © 2009 IEEE