Criminalising Survival: Images and Reality of Street
Children
ARNON BAR-ON*
(Received 25.5.95; Accepted 30.8.95)
ABSTRACT
Street children might not be securely lodged in the life-patterns that the
middle class impose on young people, but their reward from trying to
maintain a minimum standard of living that their parents and govern-
ments are unable to provide them is infinitely preferable to living in the
absolute poverty that surrounds them. Based on a critique of our current
knowledge of the maturation of children, which is informed primarily by
Northern mores and ‘scientific’ proofs whose findings derive from this
normative framework and feed back into it, this article seeks to explain
why we find child streetism so abhorrent and take it for granted that cer-
tain norms can, and should, prevail in the South just because they are
found in Northern societies.
Upon embarking on a career in social work, a friend and I were advised
by her father to defer our choice until we turned forty when, in Jewish
tradition, we should reach the age of sagacity. A survivor of the
Holocaust who lost his entire family to the Nazi atrocities, he suggested
that social workers have a morbid fascination for painting everything
dark: ‘Even in the poorest of families, children laugh and play, but social
workers look only at their bellies and seek signs of neglect.’
This was in the late 1960s, when few young people listened to anyone
over thirty. Yet I have often been reminded of these words, most recently
when pursuing the literature on street children that, with a singular
exception (Oliveira et al., 1992), systematically ignores its own findings
in favour of predetermined conclusions grounded in Northern, middle-
class mores. This article highlights a number of these discarded facts on
street children, suggests why they are neglected and consequently draws
somewhat different recommendations on child streetism than those com-
monly propagated by the caring professions.
The material draws mainly on three studies in Africa – two by the late
Peter Taçon (1991a, 1991b) which cover Namibia and Zambia, and one
* Senior Lecturer, Department of Social Work, University of Botswana.
Jnl Soc. Pol., 26, 1, 63–78 Copyright © 1997 Cambridge University Press 63