the north the hemispheric mode is dominat-
ed by the North Atlantic and Arctic regions,
with only a weak link to the north Pacific (C.
Deser, Natl Center for Atmospheric Res.,
Boulder, Colorado)
4
. Which of these views of
the NAO is the more useful therefore
depends on the research agenda. For
instance, for studies of seasonal predictabili-
ty in the Atlantic region it is usually better to
concentrate on the NAO.
Another aspect is that the NAO may not
always have shown the same behaviour. Indi-
rect data for the past four centuries suggest
that the amplitude of variability might have
increased significantly after the end of the
Little Ice Age, around 1850 (E. Cook, Lam-
ont–Doherty Earth Obs., Palisades, New
York). Moreover, the consequences of the
pattern, for example on sea-ice extent in the
Arctic (J. E. Walsh, Univ. Illinois, Urbana-
Champaign), depend on the exact positions
of the two pressure centres — which can dif-
fer significantly in years with the same index
value.
The persistent positive trend in the index
since about 1960 raises the question of
whether global warming is responsible.
There is no clear answer. A new index, based
on surface pressures from Gibraltar, Reyk-
javik in Iceland and Ponte Delgada in the
Azores, shows a similar trend for the early
part of the twentieth century (P. Yiou, Lab.
des Sciences du Climat et de L’Environ-
nement, Gif-sur-Yvette), implying that nat-
ural variability can account for Europe’s
mild and wet winters since 1960. But an
analysis of the Lisbon–Iceland index indi-
cates that natural variability can be rejected
as a cause for the recent trend (S. B. Feldstein,
Univ. Pennsylvania). After considering these
conflicting results and the processes that
drive variations of the NAO, most partici-
pants, asked to give their best guess for the
coming decade, expected the index to
increase further, rather than decline towards
the mean as would be expected in the absence
of a link with climate change.
Two main candidate mechanisms
emerged that might explain the long-term
persistence of trends in the lower atmos-
phere (in which disturbances can normally
be tracked for only about a week). Interac-
tions with the ocean are one possibility. A
statistical analysis of observations reveals
two patterns of Atlantic sea surface tempera-
tures that tend to precede specific phases of
the NAO: positive anomalies in mid-latitude
temperatures induce a positive phase with a
lead time of six months, and the tropical
Atlantic surface temperatures exert a weaker
influence on timescales of up to two months
(A. Czaja, Massachusetts Inst. Technol.).
The other candidate mechanism is
atmospheric, and centres on the polar
stratospheric vortex — a rotating circulation
pattern in the higher levels of the atmosphere
above the poles. Depending on its strength,
the vortex acts as a window that allows
atmospheric waves originating in the tropo-
sphere to pass into the upper atmosphere, or
as a mirror reflecting the waves back down.
This second phenomenon could amplify a
positive NAO phase if there is interference
between the reflected waves and the original
waves (H.-F. Graf, MPI für Meteorologie,
Hamburg)
5
.
Both sea surface temperatures and the
strength of the polar stratospheric vortex are
thought to increase with increasing green-
house gases in the atmosphere. So this con-
sideration points to a causal connection
between global warming and the positive
trend of recent years. If this is indeed the case,
there could be a beneficial effect: simulations
with a general circulation model suggest that
a positive NAO may temporarily mitigate
one of the most worrying possible impacts of
global warming, the slowing of the thermo-
haline circulation in the North Atlantic (T. L.
Delworth, Geophys. Fluid Dynamics Lab.,
Princeton Univ.). This circulation is one of
the main engines of heat transport around
the globe — if it slowed or stopped, the cli-
matic consequences would be severe.
The NAO has a considerable impact on
natural ecology and human economies, in
arenas ranging from plant and animal popu-
lation dynamics to energy production in
Scandinavia. So many researchers are
attempting to predict its behaviour on both
seasonal and decadal timescales. At the sea-
sonal scale, the aim is to exploit the predictive
value of sea surface temperatures. According
to one forecast, in which observed Atlantic
sea surface temperatures for May and
November 2000 were fed into a model, there
is a 66% chance of a positive NAO for the
coming winter (M. Rodwell, Hadley Centre,
Reading, Berks.). If increasing greenhouse-
gas concentrations in the atmosphere are
driving the current positive phase, we should
expect further increases in the frequency of
mild, wet winters in northern Europe. But to
confirm whether global warming does
indeed change the balance between the posi-
tive and negative phases, we will simply have
to wait until a clear, tell-tale signal emerges
from the noise of natural variability. ■
Heike Langenberg is an associate editor at Nature.
1. Hurrell, J. W. Science 269, 676–679 (1995).
2. Thompson, D. W. J. & Wallace, J. M. Geophys. Res. Lett. 25,
1297–1300 (1998).
3. Walker, G. T. & Bliss, E. W. Mem. R. Meteorol. Soc. 4, 53–84
(1932).
4. Deser, C. Geophys. Res. Lett. 27, 779–782 (2000).
5. Perlwitz, J. & Graf, H.-J. J. Clim. 8, 2281–2295 (1995).
news and views
NATURE | VOL 408 | 21/28 DECEMBER 2000 | www.nature.com 925
Figure 1 Deviations from a 52-year average of
sea-level atmospheric pressures over the North
Atlantic region, during winters with a high
North Atlantic Oscillation index (1 standard
deviation above the average). Anomalously large
differences between pressures over Iceland and
Lisbon lead to a strong storm track in the North
Atlantic, bringing mild, wet and stormy weather
to northern Europe. The data are derived from
measurements for the months December to
March, for 1948–99. Units are hectopascals
(ǃmillibars). (Graphic courtesy of Thomas Jung
and Michael Hilmer.)
–1
–1
1
1
2
0
0
0
0
0
–2
–3
T
he development of materials with
dimensions in the nanoscale range is a
highly active area of research because
they often have very different properties
from the bulk material. These properties can
offer new or improved technological appli-
cations. So far, materials scientists interested
in nanotechnology have mostly focused on
semiconductors and ceramics. For example,
semiconductors made from nanocrystals
have unusual optical, electrical and magnet-
ic properties, and ceramics made from nano-
particles have greater hardness and plasticity
than normal. However, on page 946 of this
issue, Maier and colleagues
1
demonstrate
that restructuring simple ionic crystals at
the nanoscale can also alter their electrical
properties, pointing the way to potentially
Nanotechnology
Solid progress in ion conduction
Alan V. Chadwick
Materials that conduct ions are useful in devices involving electrochemical
reactions, such as fuel cells and batteries. Low ionic conductivity was a
problem for these materials until researchers built nanoscale versions.
© 2000 Macmillan Magazines Ltd