181
Land Contamination & Reclamation, 16 (3), 2008 © 2008 EPP Publications Ltd
DOI 10.2462/09670513.898
Experimental woodland establishment on brick clays in
southern England
A.J. Moffat, T.R. Hutchings, I. Tubby, K.R. Butt and C.N. Lowe
Abstract
A series of long-term field experiments examining a range of reclamation options for the establish-
ment of woodland on Oxford Clay soil-forming materials restored after landfilling is described. Hostile
soil physical and nutritional characteristics prevent normal tree survival and growth, but the experi-
ments show that there are limited options to alleviate these conditions. The combined results show
that tree species of alder, poplar and willow planted on loose-tipped mounds are most suited to the
soil conditions, although growth is slow. Application of organic fertilizers has mixed effects.
Key words: community woodland; field experimentation; land reclamation; Oxford Clay; tree
establishment
INTRODUCTION
The quarrying of clay for brick making has been one of
the largest causes of land disturbance by an extractive
industry in England, and remains an important one
today (Bloodworth et al. 2001). The principal clayey
sedimentary lithologies have all been exploited, partic-
ularly from Carboniferous, Triassic, Jurassic and Creta-
ceous formations. In southern Britain, the Jurassic
Oxford Clay has been especially important in the 20th
century, partly because of the proximity to the Home
Counties’ markets and partly because the organic car-
bon content in the clay helps significantly to reduce
energy costs associated with brick firing. It has been
estimated that there are nearly 5000 km
2
of Oxford
Clay outcropping in Great Britain, of which approxi-
mately 180 km
2
are workable for brick clay.
1
Bedford-
shire is the county most associated with brick making
on this geology, but brickworks have also been located
in Buckinghamshire and Cambridgeshire. Excepting
the Chiltern woodlands in southern Buckinghamshire,
these counties have sparse tree cover. It has been recog-
nized for several decades that establishing woodland on
land restored after clay extraction could be a good
opportunity to increase woodland cover, and an appro-
priate land type on which to do so. In the majority of
brick-clay sites, reclamation has taken place in con-
junction with the infilling of clay pits with domestic and
industrial wastes, though weathered Oxford Clays are
invariably used to generate ‘soil-forming materials’ on
which to establish the vegetation cover.
Forest Research (the research agency of the Forestry
Commission) has been studying tree establishment
techniques on land affected by brick clay extraction for
several decades. Experimental work began at Elstow,
south Bedfordshire in the early 1980s, and was fol-
lowed by a series of experiments at Calvert, in Buck-
inghamshire and at Brogborough in Bedfordshire.
Existing experiments have been recently reviewed on
site, and this paper reports on the collective results and
1. http://www.mmc.gov.uk/rep_pub/reports/1976_1979/full-
text/088c05.pdf
Received February 2008; accepted May 2008
Authors
A.J. Moffat,
1
* T.R. Hutchings,
1
I. Tubby,
2
K.R. Butt
3
and C.N.
Lowe
3
1. Environmental and Human Sciences Division, Forest
Research, Alice Holt Lodge, Farnham, Surrey, GU10 4LH, UK
2. Biometrics, Surveys and Statistics Division, Forest
Research, Alice Holt Lodge, Farnham, Surrey, GU10 4LH, UK
3. School of Built and Natural Environment, University of
Central Lancashire, Preston PR1 2HE, UK
* Corresponding author (Tel. +44 1420 526202; email
andy.moffat@forestry.gsi.gov.uk)