Technology
High-Power Diode Laser in
Neurosurgery: Clinical Experience
in 30 Cases
Bertrand C. Devaux, M.D., Franc ¸ois-Xavier Roux, M.D., Franc ¸ois Nataf, M.D.,
Barish Turak, M.D., and Corneliu Cioloca, M.D.
Department of Neurosurgery, Sainte-Anne Hospital Center, Paris, France
Devaux BC, Roux F-X, Nataf F, Turak B, Cioloca C. High-power
diode laser in neurosurgery: Clinical experience in 30 cases. Surg
Neurol 1998;50:33– 40.
BACKGROUND
High-power semiconductor diode lasers were recently
introduced and have been tested in ophthalmology and
general surgery. These lasers are attractive from the
practical and economical standpoint, and have enough
power to perform most surgical procedures. They could
replace other surgical lasers such as CO
2
, argon, 1.06 m,
and 1.32 m Nd-YAG lasers for many applications in neu-
rosurgery. We report our initial experience with the first
available 0.805-m surgical diode laser, the Diomed 25
(Diomed, Ltd, Cambridge, U.K.) in a series of 30 patients.
METHODS
The diode laser was evaluated during surgical resection
of various types of central nervous system tumors in 30
patients. It was used free-hand in 27 patients in contact
and non-contact, continuous wave (cw) and pulsed
modes, and during ventricular endoscopy in three pa-
tients. Average time of laser use during a procedure was
248 seconds. Output power ranged from 1 to 25 watts,
with an average power per patient of 2.64 to 15.5 watts
(mean, 8.78 watts). Total energy delivered ranged from 65
to 11,051 joules per patient.
RESULTS
Using 600- or 400-m non-contact optic fiber, well pig-
mented tumor tissue hemostasis was obtained at cw 3 to
10 watts with a defocused beam, whereas vaporization
required 10-25 cw or pulsed watts with a focused beam.
Soft and tough tissue section could be obtained using a
sculpted cone-shaped (600-300 m tip) contact fiber at
7-10 cw watts after fiber tip charring. Because of the
deeper penetration of 0.805-m light in non-pigmented
tissues, non-contact mode is not recommended for white
matter or poorly vascularized tumors. The contact mode
was not efficient on very soft tissues such as edematous
brain parenchyma. The contact fibers proved to be very
fragile because of heat generation.
CONCLUSIONS
The high power diode laser proved to be efficient for
hemostasis, section and vaporization, using contact and
non-contact modes, at different output powers. Econom-
ical and ergonomical advantages of this new generation
of surgical lasers may cause them to replace other surgi-
cal lasers such as argon, CO
2
, and Nd-YAG lasers, mostly
for tumor surgery. © 1998 by Elsevier Science Inc.
KEY WORDS
Diode laser, surgical lasers, tumor removal, neuroendoscopy.
T
he application of lasers in neurosurgery both
experimentally and clinically started in the
late 1970s with the use of CO
2
[2,18], followed by
1.06-m Nd-YAG [3,40], argon [4,27], and more re-
cently by the 1.32-m Nd-YAG [24,30,31], and 1.44
m Nd-YAG [21] lasers. Today, these laser sources
are widely used by neurosurgeons, mostly for the
removal of intracranial and spinal cord tumors, as
well as vascular malformations, and have well
documented properties and indications during neu-
rosurgical procedures [12,14,32,33]. The major dis-
advantages of these lasers are their poor maneu-
verability because of their bulk and necessary
setup such as power supply, water and gas equip-
ment; cumbersome articulated arms for the CO
2
laser; and high purchase and maintenance cost.
Therefore, the recently developed high-power di-
ode lasers seem to be attractive from practical and
economical standpoints [20]. Recent experiments
on different tissues—from animals and surgically
removed human tissues— demonstrated the potential
benefits of diode lasers in surgery [19,28,29,41,42].
After experiments on the brains of rabbits [8], we
started to use the first commercially available high
power diode laser in neurosurgical practice [7,9].
We report here our initial experience in a series of
30 neurosurgical procedures.
Address reprint requests to: Dr. Bertrand C. Devaux, Service de Neuro-
chirurgie, Centre Hospitalier Sainte-Anne. 1, Rue Cabanis, 75674 Paris
Cedex, France.
Received March 12, 1996; accepted November 21, 1997.
© 1998 by Elsevier Science Inc. 0090-3019/98/$19.00
655 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10010 PII S0090-3019(98)00042-1