Comparison of different equations of state in a model based on
VdWeP for prediction of CO
2
hydrate formation pressure in Lw-H-V
phase and a new correlation to degrade error of the model
Seyed Ashkan Naghibzade
a
, Hamzeh Kahrizi
a
, Amin Soleimani Mehr
b, *
a
National Iranian Oil Company, West Oil and Gas Production Company, Iran
b
Sh. Hasheminejad Gas Processing Co., National Iranian Gas. Co, Sarakhs, Iran
article info
Article history:
Received 9 August 2014
Received in revised form
24 November 2014
Accepted 27 November 2014
Available online
Keywords:
VdWeP
AADP
Hydrate formation
Empirical correlations
abstract
Carbon dioxide plays a significant role in global warming. Formation of carbon dioxide hydrate is one of
the several ways to remove this gas from the atmosphere. In order to attain a proper process design,
pressure and temperature of the hydrate formation should be estimated.
The empirical correlations, charts and thermodynamic model scan be used to predict these conditions.
In this work, a model based on van der WaalsePlatteeuw for prediction of hydrate formation condi-
tions of CO
2
which uses four different equations of state, PR, RK, PT and ALS in L
w
-H-V phase and in
temperature range of 271.6 Ke283.2 K is used and the results are brought out in order to compare with
each other and with experimental data reported in the literature.
Among PR, PT, RK and ALS equations of state, PR with total AADP of 2.52% shows better results than
other equations of state.
For the model based on VdWeP which uses PR as an equation of state a correlation is presented in
order to reduce the amount of error which appears at high temperatures. This correlation reduces the
amount of AADP for temperatures of hydrate formation higher than 280.44 K from 4.42 % to 1.04%.
© 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The increasing demand of energy supply, as a result of industrial
developments and elevation of standards of human life, has led to
accelerate mining and combustion of fossil fuels. These worldwide
activities cause a continuing increase in producing anthropogenic
carbon dioxide (CO
2
), resulting in increase of the level of atmo-
spheric carbon dioxide (Sabil et al., 2011). According to Robinson
et al. (Robinson et al., 2007), the atmospheric carbon dioxide level
has increased 22% since 1958 and about 30% since 1880.
CO
2
is considered to be the largest contributor to the global
warming problem, and is thus the major target for reduction. In
recent years idea of sequestrating global warming gases mainly
CO
2
, in the form of CO
2
hydrate as a method to hold the CO
2
con-
centration below a given level has been proposed.
Gas hydrates or clathrate hydrates are ice-like crystalline com-
pounds, which are formed through a combination of water and
guest molecules under suitable conditions of low temperature and
high pressures (Sloan and Koh, 2007).
The majority of gas hydrates are known in three common crystal
structures: structure I (sI), structure II (sII) and structure H (sH),
where each structure is composed of a certain number of cavities
formed by water molecules (Mohammadi and Richon, 2009).
CO
2
has been known to be among a number of molecules that
can form clathrate hydrate as a simple hydrate, carbon dioxide
forms structure I hydrate under appropriate pressure and temper-
ature conditions (Khalik, 2009).
So far, several studies have been performed on the prediction of
hydrate forming conditions for various gases. Generally, methods
for prediction of hydrate phase equilibrium are empirical correla-
tions, charts or thermodynamic models. A variety of thermody-
namic models for the calculation of phase equilibrium properties of
the hydrate system have been discussed, which some of these
methods are based on a statistical thermodynamic approach
developed by van der Waals and Platteeuw model.
In this work, van der WaalsePlatteeuw model (Parrish and
Prausnitz Development)is used for prediction of hydrate formation
conditions of
CO2
with application of four different equations of
* Corresponding author. Gas Engineering Department, Petroleum University of
Technology, 63431, Ahwaz, Iran.
E-mail address: petro.amin@gmail.com (A. Soleimani Mehr).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jngse
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jngse.2014.11.035
1875-5100/© 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 22 (2015) 292e298