Europ.J.Protistol. 27, 207-219 (1991)
September 9, 1991
Protist Evolution and Phylogeny as Discerned
from Small Subunit Ribosomal RNA Sequence
Comparisons
1
Martin Schlegel
Zoologisches Institut, Abteilung Zellbiologie, Universite: Tiibingen, Tiibingen, FRG
Summary
Ribosomal RNA sequence comparisons reveal an evolutionary diversity among unicellular
eukaryotes far exceeding that observed within the multicellular or prokaryote kingdoms. The
analysis of small subunit ribosomal RNAs provides new insights into the evolution and
phylogenetic relationships of major lineages. The parasitic diplomonad flagellate Giardia
lamblia diverges first on the eukaryotic tree, followed by another parasite, the microsporidian
Vairimorpha necatrix, Further, a close relationship between apicomplexa, dinoflagellates and
ciliates is evident from sequence comparisons. The eumycetes or true fungi are separated from
the oomycetes. However, phylogenetic relationships between the major protist lineages, as well
as their relationships to both prokaryotes and multicellular organisms cannot be discerned by
analysis of small subunit rRNA sequences alone. Additional molecular information, for example
from large subunit rRNA, or polymerase genes are requested to gain confidence in branching
patterns displayed in the small subunit rRNA trees. Advantages and disadvantages of commonly
used treeing methods are briefly discussed as well as the current views on the phylogenetic
relationships between eukaryotes, archaebacteria and eubacteria.
Review
Contents I Introduction
Summary
I Introduction
II Molecular Markers
III Construction of Phylogenetic Trees
IV Phylogenetic Relationships Between Eukaryota,
Archaebacteria and Eubacteria
V The "Early Branches"
VI Rapid Proliferation of Major Groups
VII Conclusions
References
1 Modified version of an invited lecture held at the 9th
meeting of the German Society of Protozoology,
15.03.-17.03.1990 in Helgoland, FRG.
© 1991 by Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart
Unicellular eukaryotes have been studied for more than
300 years. Their abundant morphological variation and
beauty was pointed out, among others, by Ernst Haeckel
[41]. He gave the protists kingdom rank [40] more than
120 years ago. Therein he recognized eight different phyla:
Moneres (prokaryotes), Diatomeae, Protoplasta, Myxo-
cystoda, Flagellata, Rhizopoda, Myxomycetes and Spon-
giae (Fig. 1). Later, a great ultrastructural, physiological
and biochemical diversity, far exceeding that of multicel-
lular organisms, was revealed among protists [55,63, 79,
81]. Despite the expanding data base, the phylogenetic
relationships of the protists and also the origin of the
eukaryotic ancestor remained unclear. It is puzzling that
our understanding of the phylogenetic and evolutionary
relationships even among the major lines of descent is still
so unsatisfactory [78]. As a result, an increasing number of
often conflicting classification schemes emerged [8, 9, 12,
55, 58, 63, 64, 68, 104]. In some of them, the term
"Protista" is maintained [12] implying that all members of
0932-4739/91/0027-0207$3.50/0