Geometric-mechanical origin of global planetary angular momentum dynamics
Ramses van der Toorn ⁎
Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Math & Computer Science, Delft University of Technology, Mekelweg 4, 2628CD Delft, The Netherlands
abstract article info
Article history:
Received 24 August 2011
Received in revised form 31 July 2012
Accepted 9 August 2012
Available online 21 August 2012
Keywords:
Planetary Fluid Dynamics
Angular Momentum Dynamics
Variational Principle
Symmetry
In this paper we shall derive integral angular momentum equations for shallow water dynamics on a rotating
planet and in doing so we shall show that these equations are a consequence of the partial spherical symme-
try of an appropriate Lagrangian density for this dynamics.
© 2012 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
In this paper we shall derive integral angular momentum equa-
tions for shallow water dynamics on a rotating planet. In particular,
we shall show that these equations are a consequence of the partial
spherical symmetry of an appropriate Lagrangian density for plane-
tary shallow water dynamics.
Our derivation is inspired by the methodology behind Noether's the-
orem. Noether's theorem presents conservation laws as consequences
of symmetries of a dynamical system. We will show that by applying
the methodology behind Noether's theorem to the specific case of plan-
etary shallow water dynamics, one can derive a set of criteria, that must
be simultaneously met by a transformation for that transformation to
be a symmetry. We shall subsequently show that in the specific case
at hand, as a next step, the notion of symmetry can actually be relaxed,
simply by exploring transformations that meet not all, but only some of
the criteria for symmetry. Obviously, with such transformations, no
conservation laws will be associated. As we shall explicitly show in
the present paper however, by the geometrical, spherical symmetry of
a planet, a set of three equations for the balance of integral angular mo-
mentum of a shallow fluid layer on a rotating planet is implied in this
manner. The spherical symmetry of a planet, which as we shall show
is essentially three dimensional, does not correspond to a three dimen-
sional symmetry of planetary fluid dynamics. This is mainly because the
rotation of the planet defines an axis, and hence a direction in space.
Therefore, a single conservation law only can be expected to be
associated with rotations, namely one associated with rotations about
the axis of the planet. As we shall show in the present paper however,
the full three dimensional spherical symmetry, associated with only
the spherical shape of the planet, still implies a set of three equations
for integral angular momentum.
Noether's theorem builds on the variational formulation of mechan-
ics, which was first introduced by Lagrange (1736–1813). This formal-
ism has the so called Lagrangian function L as its central quantity.
According to the Lagrangian formulation of mechanics (Goldstein,
1980; Lanczos, 1970), motions that are realized in nature always corre-
spond to extremes of a so-called action integral, which in turn has the
Lagrangian L as its argument. The corresponding (differential) equa-
tions of motion are the Euler–Lagrange equations associated with the
same Lagrangian function L. Because the Lagrangian function is a key in-
gredient to Noether's theorem, and hence to our analysis, in Section 2
we shall introduce a Lagrangian density function L, appropriate for plan-
etary shallow water dynamics.
Given the material discussed so far, a first issue to be clarified is the
issue of spherical symmetry of a rotating planet. In an explicit analysis of
the approximate spherical symmetry of rotating planets, Van der Toorn
and Zimmerman (2008) demonstrated that due to a delicate balance
between (a) Newtonian gravitational forces, as induced by the mass
distribution of the planet, and (b) centrifugal forces as observed in a co-
ordinate system that is co-rotating with the planet, at least in the con-
text of planetary fluid dynamics (PFD), the mean geometry of the
planet may indeed be approximated by that of a simple sphere. This
means that, in terms of e.g. momentum balance equations, with respect
to a co-rotating coordinate system the only consequence for PFD in-
duced by the rotation of the planet is the occurrence of Coriolis terms.
In co-rotating coordinate systems, centrifugal effects are balanced by
gravitational effects induced by the oblateness of the planet, while
other dynamical effects induced by the oblateness can be shown to be
negligible compared to e.g. Coriolis effects (van der Toorn, 1997).
A second issue to be clarified at this stage concerns the motivation
behind the key subject of this paper. We shall address this issue in
Journal of Sea Research 74 (2012) 45–51
⁎ Tel.: +31 152787281.
E-mail address: R.vanderToorn@TUDelft.nl.
1385-1101/$ – see front matter © 2012 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.seares.2012.08.006
Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect
Journal of Sea Research
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/seares