pubs.acs.org/JAFC Published on Web 12/30/2010 © 2010 American Chemical Society
J. Agric. Food Chem. 2011, 59, 645–653 645
DOI:10.1021/jf102960g
Effect of Soil Wetting and Drying Cycles on Metolachlor Fate in
Soil Applied as a Commercial or Controlled-Release
Formulation
OSNAT GOLDREICH,
†
Y AAKOV GOLDWASSER,
‡
AND Y AEL G. MISHAEL*
,†
†
Department of Soil and Water and
‡
RH Smith Institute of Plant Science and Genetics in Agriculture,
The Robert H. Smith Faculty of Agriculture, Food and Environment,
The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Rehovot 76100, Israel
A controlled-release formulation (CRF) has been developed for metolachlor, which reduced its
leaching in a sandy soil and improved weed control in comparison with the commercial formula-
tion. The current study tested the effect of soil wetting and drying cycles (WDCs) on metolachlor
fate (desorption, leaching, and weed control) applied as the CRF and as the commercial formula-
tion. Metolachlor adsorption to a heavy soil (Terra-Rosa) was predominately to the clay minerals and
oxides. Metolachlor release from a heavy soil subjected to WDCs was higher than its release from the
soil not subjected to WDCs. Consequently, a bioassay in soil columns treated with the commercial
formulation indicated enhanced metolachlor leaching in heavy soils under WDCs. In contrast, when
metolachlor was applied as the CRF, leaching was suppressed and not affected by WDCs. These
results emphasize the advantages of the CRF also in heavy soils subjected to WDCs.
KEYWORDS: Metolachlor; controlled-release formulations; wetting and drying cycles; leaching
INTRODUCTION
Applying herbicides provides substantial agronomic and eco-
nomic benefits; however, in some cases their use poses environ-
mental issues, due to leaching and surface migration, which cause
soil, surface water, and groundwater contamination ( 1-3 ). Further-
more, migration and leaching reduce herbicide concentration at
the topsoil, which reduces weed control efficacy. Insufficient weed
control brings an increase in herbicide application dose and
frequency, which further increase treatment costs and environ-
mental contamination.
Herbicide leaching in the soil is governed by several factors,
such as soil structure and characteristics, chemophysical proper-
ties of herbicides, and the effects of climatic conditions and tillage
methods ( 1 , 4 ). Among climate conditions the effects of rain and
irrigation on herbicide leaching have been widely explored ( 5 , 6 ).
For example, heavy rain intensities and high irrigation frequen-
cies have been found to enhance the migration of metolachlor
(MTC) in sandy soil ( 5 ). In contrast, very little is reported on
another important impact of climate, the influence of wetting and
drying cycles (WDCs).
The phenomenon of WDCs implies that the soil undergoes
frequent changes in water content due to rain events or irrigation
accompanied by dry periods. This phenomenon is most pro-
nounced in semiarid areas. WDCs of the soil affect herbicide fate
in the soil and in particular their persistence, leaching, migration,
sorption to soil particles, and degradation ( 7 ). A number of
studies have shown that microbial degradation of herbicides is
inhibited during drying cycles, which enhances their persistence in
soil ( 8 -11 ). The effect of WDCs on adsorption/desorption of
herbicides was less studied and is less understood. Different
trends are reported on this effect; for example, imazaquin
desorption from the soil increased following WDCs ( 9 ), whereas
diuron ( 12 , 13 ) and atrazine ( 8 ) desorption was reduced due to
WDCs. The main mechanism suggested was strong adsorption of
the herbicide to soil organic matter.
Metolachlor is a selective preplant herbicide that controls a
broad spectrum of grass weeds and small-seeded broadleaves in
many crops and is widely used worldwide mainly in corn, soybean,
sunflower, sugar beet, potato, and cotton. Its adsorption to the
soil is considered to be moderate and is positively correlated with
soil organic matter and clay content ( 14-20 ). Its water solubility
is relatively high (S
w
= 488 mg/L, 20 °C); therefore, it is prone
to extensive leaching and has been detected in groundwater
( 14 , 21-25 ).
One of the approaches pursued to reduce herbicide migration
in soil while maintaining suitable weed control is developing
controlled-release formulations (CRFs) ( 26 -30 ). We have designed
a CRF for metolachlor based on herbicide solubilization in
micelles and adsorption of the mixed micelles on clay minerals
( 31 ). This formulation was tested and found to reduce metola-
chlor leaching through a sandy soil column and improve weed
control in comparison with the commercial formulation. In the
current study the effect of WDCs on metolachlor desorption,
leaching, and weed control in the soil was investigated.
We hypothesized that the CRF will moderate the negative
effects of WDCs on metolachlor behavior, that is, desorption,
leaching, and weed control efficiency. Therefore, the CRF’s
*Corresponding author (phone 972-8-948-9171; fax 972-8-948-9856;
e-mail mishael@agri.huji.ac.il).