Letter to the Editor
Urinary ascites in a fetus with posterior urethral valve:
Antenatal diagnosis
Tomoyuki Kuwata,
1
Shigeki Matsubara,
1
Shigeru Nakamura
2
and Hideo Nakai
2
Department of
1
Obstetrics and Gynecology and Jichi Perinatal Education Center, and
2
Pediatric Urology, Jichi Medical
University, Shimotsuke, Tochigi, Japan
Posterior urethral valves are reportedly associated with urine
collection in the retroperitoneal or abdominal cavity in 1.0–
8.5% of cases,
1
with the latter, urinary ascites, being less fre-
quent.
1
Although the mechanism of urinary ascites is unclear,
bladder rupture is one culprit.
1
We read the article by Gürgöze
et al., “A rare case of ascites in a newborn: posterior urethral
valve”,
2
in which posterior urethral valve caused kidney
rupture, not bladder rupture, leading to urinary ascites in a
17-day-old boy. The authors emphasized that in this condition,
urinary ascites can be caused by not only bladder rupture, but
also urine extravasation from the upper urinary tract, also pre-
viously reported to be a culprit of neonatal urinary ascites.
3
The
report by Gürgöze et al.
2
ended with, “antenatal ultrasonogra-
phy should be performed in all pregnant women”, which was
not performed in this case.
We agree with this comment. We experienced a similar case of
urinary ascites due to urine extravasation from the upper urinary
tract associated with posterior urethral valve, but in a fetus, not a
neonate. Antenatal ultrasound worked. Ultrasound in the 26th
week revealed giant bladder (megacystis) and bilateral hydro-
nephrosis in a male fetus (Fig. 1a). In the 28th week, ascites
appeared, and the mother was referred. Megacystis and bilateral
hydronephrosis, which had been observed 2 weeks previously,
were absent. Massive ascites (Fig. 1b) pushed the diaphragm
cephalad, compressing the thoracic cavity. Retroperitoneal fluid
collection around the left kidney was observed (Fig. 1c). The most
probable antenatal diagnosis was as follows: distal urinary tract
obstruction, such as posterior urethral valve, caused megacystis
and hydronephrosis. Urine was extravasated from the left upper
urinary tract, finally leading to urinary ascites. The next day (28
2/7
weeks of gestation), Doppler flowmetry revealed mitral/tricuspid
regurgitation, a heart failure sign, possibly caused by thoracic
compression by ascites, requiring emergency cesarean section.
The male infant weighed 1470 g with 1/5-min Apgar scores of 3/7.
Ultrasound revealed massive ascites and fluid retention around the
left kidney. Cystoscopy revealed no bladder rupture. Posterior
Correspondence: Shigeki Matsubara, MD, PhD, Department of Obstet-
rics and Gynecology, Jichi Medical University, 3311-1 Shimotsuke,
Tochigi 329-0498, Japan. Email: matsushi@jichi.ac.jp
Received 3 June 2010; revised 6 December 2010; accepted 22
December 2010.
(b) (a) (c)
Fig. 1 Ultrasound findings at (a) 26th and (b,c) 28th week of gestation. (a) Arrowheads and arrow indicate bilateral hydronephrosis and
megacystis, respectively. (b) Arrowheads and arrow indicate kidneys and ascites, respectively. Bilateral hydronephrosis (arrowheads in Fig. 1a)
disappeared. (c) Asterisk indicates retroperitoneal fluid, suggesting retroperitoneal urinary collection (extravasated urine). Arrow indicates
ascites. Arrowheads show the kidney. Note the absence of hydronephrosis.
Pediatrics International (2011) 53, 281–282 doi: 10.1111/j.1442-200X.2011.03344.x
© 2011 The Authors
Pediatrics International © 2011 Japan Pediatric Society