Anarchist Studies 29.1 © 2021 issn 2633 8270
www.lwbooks.co.uk/journals/anarchiststudies/
DOI:10.3898/AS.29.1.05
Evil Institutions: Steven Bartlett’s
Analysis of Human Evil and its
Relevance for Anarchist Alternatives
Brian Martin
ABSTRACT
The study of human evil, defined in a non-religious sense as serious damage to
other people, animals and the environment, can be used to assess different social
arrangements. Steven Bartlett’s analysis of the pathologies of human behaviour
and thought provides a fruitful starting point for examining social institutions.
Systems based on hierarchy and control, notably the military, bureaucracy and the
state, provide the greatest facilitation of evil. Egalitarian systems are better placed
to restrain the human capacity for causing harm. The study of evil offers a useful
approach for understanding both the advantages of anarchism and the obstacles to
moving towards it.
Keywords: evil, social institutions, anarchism, bureaucracy, the state, the family
INTRODUCTION
It is easy to observe that humans, as individuals and as a species, do many things
damaging to each other, to other species, and to the environment that supports
them all. War, torture, terrorism, dictatorship, racism and systematic exploitation
are just some of the toxic features of human societies. As well, humans enslave and
exploit numerous other species, while humans themselves overpopulate and destroy
the ecological systems that support life on earth. This is a roll call of destructive
behaviours, individual and collective.
One way to try to understand the proclivity of humans to hurt each other and
destroy the environment is through the concept of human evil. Because of its reli-