Editorial
Evolutionary Developmental Genomics: At the 2008 meeting of the European Society
for Evolutionary Developmental Biology
The second meeting of the European Society for Evolutionary
Developmental Biology (EED) was held in Ghent (Belgium) between
the 29th July and 1st August, 2008. Within this large, wide-ranging
conference we organised a symposium on Evolutionary Develop-
mental Genomics. Here we provide a brief overview of the symposium
and put the three contributions in this issue of Genomics from
Sebastian Shimeld, Antony Durston and Ron Parchem, who were
speakers in the symposium, into context.
The principle stimulus for the symposium was the incontrovertible
fact that we are living through an era of a huge, ever expanding
quantity of DNA sequence data, that is having a massive impact on so
much of biology, Evolutionary Developmental Biology included. This is
simply illustrated by the data filed with Genbank at the time of the
symposium (release 166, June 2008) representing92,008,611,867 bp.
Now, one year later (release 172, June 2009), the figure stands at
105,277,306,080 bp, a staggering increase of 13,268,694,213 bp, made
all the more stunning when one considers that this represents the
traditional divisions of Genbank and does not include the Whole
Genome Shotgun sequences. Alongside various whole-genome
sequences and expressed sequence tag (EST) projects we now have
a treasure-trove of information with which to understand and
investigate animal evolution from a much more comprehensive
point of view.
Themes running through this symposium can be broadly summar-
ized as, (1) the need to handle all of this data and navigate carefully
through it, (2) assembly of complete catalogues of developmental
genes and gene families, illustrating the prevalence of gene gains and
losses in genome and network evolution, (3) the importance of non-
coding sequences, and (4) the crucial links between genome or gene
organization and developmental mechanisms. What follows is a brief
outline of each talk besides the three covered in greater detail in the
accompanying reviews.
Silvan Oulion (CNRS Gif-sur-Yvette, France) described the Hox
gene clusters of the dogfish, Scyliorhinus canicula, following BAC clone
and EST sequencing, clarifying our understanding of patterns of gene
loss within the vertebrate Hox clusters, and revealing extensive
alternative splicing and sharing of untranslated exons between
multiple genes. This last discovery may account for a form of
constraint on Hox clustering. Intriguingly the dogfish may have lost
or severely degenerated its HoxC cluster.
Simone Kienle (Max Planck Institute for Developmental Biology,
Germany) presented the use of second-generation sequencing to
obtain the whole genome (169 Mb) of a Polish strain of the nematode,
Pristionchus pacificus, to detect SNPs relative to a Californian strain.
These SNPs are now being mapped to loci involved with the
phenotypic differences between these two strains with the aid of
recombinant inbred lines from California/Polish crosses. This repre-
sents a powerful approach to determine the genetic basis underlying
phenotypic diversity in closely related organisms.
Barbara Negre (University of Cambridge, UK) outlined the
evolution of the Achaete-Scute proneural gene cluster in insects,
utilizing the improving availability of insect whole-genome
sequences. This diversity of available genomes now permits the
detection of conserved regulatory elements, particularly amongst the
Drosophilids, as well as revealing that independent expansions of the
cluster have occurred in different lineages, which possibly relate to
functional and morphological diversification [1].
Elena Simionato (CNRS Gif-sur-Yvette, France) presented a
classification of the bHLH transcription factors of animals, from a
phylogenetically broad sample of whole genomes. There were already
10–14 families of bHLH genes before the origin of the sponges, early in
animal evolution, and there was then a large expansion of families
before the origin of the Cnidaria [2]. These genes often have
prominent roles in neurogenesis, such as the Atonal/Neurogenin
genes of bilaterians like Drosophila and vertebrates. Sponges, despite
lacking a nervous system, possess a gene that looks like a precursor to
the Atonal/Neurogenin families, which intriguingly is co-expressed
(in the so-called globular cells) with other genes orthologous to
bilaterian neuronal genes ([3] and [4]); an example of a morphological
novelty (neurons) evolving on pre-existing molecular networks and
developmental regulators.
Michael Schubert (ENS de Lyon, France) detailed the evolution of
retinoic acid (RA) signalling in development by comparison of animal
genome sequences and showed that RA signalling components were
certainly in place by the origin of the deuterostomes, but possibly even
earlier in animal evolution, at the origin of the Bilateria [5]. Moreover,
the recently completed amphioxus genome facilitated the isolation of
a large number of potential RA-target genes, which were then tested
for direct regulation by RA signalling with combinations of treatments
with RA and puromycin (to inhibit translation). This approach
revealed a selection of direct targets during gastrulation, which
include different Hox genes.
David Ferrier (University of St Andrews, UK) dealt with the
importance of analysing genomes that are less derived than many
traditional model systems in order to reconstruct ancestral states
that are the starting points for major transitions in animal evolution,
such as the origin of the chordates and Bilateria. Amphioxus is one
such suitable genome that has retained all of the homeobox gene
families that were present in the last common chordate ancestor,
whilst other chordate lineages (including humans) have lost several
families. The supposedly prototypical chordate Hox cluster of
amphioxus is now also known to contain 15 Hox genes, the
Genomics 95 (2010) 247–249
0888-7543/$ – see front matter © 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ygeno.2009.07.001
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Genomics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ygeno