Epstein-Barr Virus Vectors Provide Prolonged Robust Factor IX
Expression in Mice
Christopher R. Sclimenti, Andrew S. Neviaser,
‡
Edward J. Baba,
§
Leonard Meuse,
†
Mark A. Kay,
†
and Michele P. Calos*
Departments of Genetics and Pediatrics, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California 94305
We demonstrate that vectors incorporating components from Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)
for retention and from human genomic DNA for replication greatly enhance the level
and duration of marker gene expression in dividing cultured cells. The same types of
vectors were tested in vivo by high-pressure tail vein injection of naked DNA in mice,
resulting in liver delivery and expression. The therapeutic gene was a human factor
IX (hFIX) minigene comprising genomically derived 5′,3′, and intronic sequences that
provided relatively good gene expression in vivo. We demonstrated that addition of
the EBV EBNA1 gene and its family of repeats binding sites provided a 10- to 100-
fold increase in prolonged hFIX expression in mouse liver. A single 25-μg dose of vector
DNA generated normal (>5 μg/mL) levels of hFIX throughout the 8 month duration
of the experiment. Vector DNA with or without the EBV sequences was retained in
liver cells, and vector replication was not a factor in these nondividing liver cells.
Instead, it appears that enhancement of stable hFIX expression by the EBV
components was responsible for the increased level and duration of therapeutic gene
expression. The EBV sequences also significantly enhanced stable expression of a vector
carrying the full genomic hFIX gene delivered to mouse liver. These results underline
the crucial importance of appropriate gene expression signals on gene therapy vectors
and the utility of EBV sequences in particular for increasing stable gene expression.
Introduction
A significant issue for any gene therapy vector is
whether it can provide adequate gene expression for the
prolonged periods required in most applications. Intro-
duced DNA needs to be retained in target cells and must
continue to be well-expressed over time. The safety and
simplicity of nonintegrating plasmid vectors are appeal-
ing, but these vectors present challenges for maintenance
of stable gene expression (1). If the target cells are
dividing, then conventional nonintegrated plasmid DNA
will be lost during mitosis (2). In nondividing cells, even
though plasmid DNA may be retained, it has become
clear that persistence of introduced plasmid DNA does
not necessarily equate with continued robust gene ex-
pression. Instead, special sequences seem to be required
in order to prevent silencing of vector gene expression.
Various genomic sequences, including some genomic
promoters and/or intronic sequences, e.g., refs 3-6, have
shown positive effects in this regard. Certain viral
sequences may also protect against silencing, as explored
in this study.
After delivery of plasmid DNA to mouse liver, a typical
cDNA construct with a viral promoter, such as the human
gene encoding R
1
-antitrypsin (hAAT) driven by the CMV
promoter, gives rise to only a transient level of strong
gene expression. Gene expression then declines rapidly
over 2 weeks, even though plasmid DNA remains in the
liver cells (7). This progressive silencing of expression of
plasmid DNA is the usual result and is not confined to
liver. Silencing is probably due to cellular mechanisms
acting through chromatin features. In mouse lung similar
results were seen with CMV, RSV, and SV40 viral
promoters driving a luciferase reporter gene. Expression
fell to low levels during the first 2 weeks, even while
continued presence of plasmid DNA was documented (6).
By using genomic promoters for the cellular polyubiq-
uitin C or elongation factor 1R genes in place of the viral
promoters, increased persistence of lung gene expression
was obtained (6). Likewise, increased persistence of
human factor IX (hFIX) was seen when cellular locus
control region, promoter, and 3′ regions derived from
various genes were used, in combination with a portion
of the first intron from the native hFIX gene (3, 4). In a
further example, greatly enhanced and prolonged expres-
sion of hAAT was observed when the entire genomic gene,
as opposed to a cDNA with a viral promoter, was present
on the vector (5). These results all support the hypothesis
that some genomic sequences are effective in endowing
introduced genes with the ability to continue to be
expressed in vivo.
In addition to certain genomic sequences, observations
with Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) vectors have implicated
viral sequences such as the EBNA1 gene and its family
of repeats binding sites in long-term expression of plas-
mid DNA. In cases where the host cells are dividing, the
special replication and nuclear retention properties of
EBV vectors are beneficial and give a far better outcome
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. Ph: 650-723-
5558. Fax: 650-723-5645. E-mail: calos@stanford.edu.
†
Department of Pediatrics.
‡
Present address: Case Western Reserve School of Medicine,
10900 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44106-4920.
§
Present address: Syracuse University College of Law, Syra-
cuse, NY 13244-1030.
144 Biotechnol. Prog. 2003, 19, 144-151
10.1021/bp0200907 CCC: $25.00 © 2003 American Chemical Society and American Institute of Chemical Engineers
Published on Web 11/28/2002