THE WORLD BANK ECONOMIC REVIEW, VOL. 14, NO. 3: 457-80
What Drives Consumption Booms?
Peter J. Montiel
Consumption booms have been common in both industrial and developing countries,
and several explanations have been offered for their occurrence. These include economy-
wide wealth effects associated with favorable movements in the terms of trade or eu-
phoric expectations triggered by macroeconomic reforms, Ricardian effects associated
with fiscal stabilization, lending booms following financial liberalization, and a variety
of distortions m mtertemporal relative prices. Using a large cross-country sample of
booms, this article assesses how widely applicable these explanations are. The key find-
ing is that wealth effects linked to favorable movements in the terms of trade and antici-
pated improvements in macroeconomic performance seem to have been more important
empirically than explanations relying primarily on fiscal phenomena or distortions in
intertemporal relative prices.
Consumption booms, common in both industrial and developing countries, have
been associated with a variety of macroeconomic events, including stabilization
of high inflation, surges in capital inflows, the implementation of market-
oriented structural reforms (especially trade and financial liberalization), and fa-
vorable movements in the external terms of trade. They are often perceived as
policy problems because of their effects on demand for home goods, the trade
balance, and the resources available for investment. The emergence of a con-
sumption boom may, for example, undermine the objective of stabilizing infla-
tion by putting upward pressure on the prices of home goods. Similarly, a con-
sumption boom that arises during an episode of capital inflows may significantly
increase the country's current account deficit, which may, in turn, undermine the
credibility of the prevailing exchange rate and contribute to capital flow rever-
sals. The recent example of Mexico has now become notorious, but similar, if
relatively muted, booms have characterized several other capital-importing coun-
tries in Latin America.
Despite the occasional attention given to specific episodes, researchers have
only recently begun to study the causes of consumption booms in a systematic
way. By and large, their analysis has been confined to speculation based on ca-
sual empiricism in descriptive studies focusing on other issues (such as stabiliza-
tion episodes and surges in capital inflows).
1
In these contexts several competing
1. Exceptions include Rebelo and Vegh (1996) and Reinhart and Vegh (1995).
Peter J. Montiel is professor in the Department of Economics at Williams College. His e-mail address
is pmontiet@wiUiams.edu. The author gratefully acknowledges comments on earlier drafts from Barry
Bosworth, Carlos Vegh, and two anonymous referees.
© 2000 The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/THE WORLD BANK
457
Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized