second
language
research
Second Language Research
27(3) 361–390
© The Author(s) 2011
Reprints and permission: sagepub.
co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0267658310395866
slr.sagepub.com
Corresponding author:
Bryan Donaldson, Department of French and Italian, University of Texas at Austin, 1 University Station
B7600, Austin, TX 78712-0224, USA
Email: bdonaldson@austin.utexas.edu
Nativelike right-dislocation
in near-native French
Bryan Donaldson
University of Texas at Austin, USA
Abstract
Recent research on advanced and near-native second-language (L2) speakers has focused on the
acquisition of interface phenomena, for example at the syntax–pragmatics interface. Proponents
of the Interface Hypothesis (e.g. Sorace, 2005; Sorace and Filiaci, 2006; Tsimpli and Sorace, 2006;
Sorace and Serratrice, 2009) argue that (external) interfaces present difficulties for L2 grammars,
resulting in permanent deficits even in near-native grammars. Other research, however, has
argued that interfaces are acquirable, albeit with delays (Ivanov, 2009; Rothman, 2009). This
study examines right-dislocation (RD) in experimental and production data from near-native
French. Right-dislocation marks topic in discourse and thus requires the integration of syntactic
and discourse–pragmatic knowledge. Participants were 10 near-native speakers of French who
learned French after age 10 and whose grammatical competence was comparable to the near-
native speakers of French in Birdsong (1992), and 10 French native speakers. The data come from
two experimental tasks and an 8.5-hour corpus of spontaneous informal dyadic conversations.
The near-natives demonstrated nativelike judgments, preferences, and use of RD in authentic
discourse. Only one near-native displayed evidence of first-language (L1) transfer, which resulted
in non-nativelike use of RD. On the whole, the results suggest nativelike acquisition of this area of
the syntax–pragmatics interface and fail to provide support for the Interface Hypothesis.
Keywords
second language acquisition, syntax, dislocations, discourse, information structure, near-nativeness,
French language
I Information structure
This study discusses aspects of information structure (Lambrecht, 1994) and how it is sign-
posted syntactically in second-language (L2) near-native French. Information structure,
broadly defined, involves the flow of old and new information in discourse and consequent
syntactic, phonological, morphological, and lexical choices. The field of inquiry dates to
the Prague School (Mathesius, 1939; Firbas, 1964) and has a long functionalist tradition