American Journal of Dermatology and Venereology 2014, 3(3): 51-56
DOI: 10.5923/j.ajdv.20140303.01
An Investigation into the Effectiveness of Light Emitting
Diodes on Treating Melasma on Skin Type VI
Nomakhosi Mpofana
1,*
, Cindy Ramhurry
2
1
Department of Wellness, Cape Peninsula University of Technology, Cape Town, 8000, South Africa
²Department of Applied Communicative Skills, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, 2000, South Africa
Abstract The literature highlights the higher prevalence of the condition of Melasma in women with Fitzpatrick skin type
IV-VI and the risks and challenges involved in its treatment [1, 2, 3]. In this case study, we collected data from 6 confirmed
cases of Melasma with Fitzpatrick skin type VI via record cards and visia analyses to investigate the effectiveness of Light
Emitting Diodes (LED 633nm and 830nm) as a relatively risk free form of treatment. We specifically found that the LED
(633nm and 830nm) generally improved skin texture, evened out skin tone, reduced the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles,
refined enlarged pores and reduced porphyrins in the skin. In conclusion, we found evidence that LED (633nm and 830nm)
may be effective in treating melasma in skin type VI.
Keywords Melasma, Skin type VI, LED, Treatment, Prevalence
1. Introduction
Recent literature has shown an alarming increase in the
occurrence of Melasma- an acquired, chronic, recurrent
darkening of the skin on the face [4, 5]. The literature
highlights the higher prevalence of this condition in women
with Fitzpatrick skin type IV-VI and the risks involved in its
treatment [1, 2, 3]. Writers contend that the wide spectrum of
melanin absorption (250-1200nm) in darker skin types
causes conditions such as post inflammatory
hyperpigmentation, blistering, scabbing and in some cases,
skin atrophy [6, 7]. Due to its disfiguring nature, melasma
has been documented as a condition resulting in significant
negative psychological and emotional impact [8]. Recent
studies indicate a decrease in social functioning, decreased
productivity at work and the lowering of self-esteem [9].
The literature highlights the challenge in treating melasma
in skin type VI. Most documented attempts have primarily
relied on the use of invasive therapy, drugs and creams: these
include ablative and non-ablative lasers, micro-
dermabrasion, mesotherapy and topical de-pigmenting
agents such as Hydroquinone, Kojic acid, Arbutin, Retinoids,
Niacinamide, Mequinol, Kligman’s formula, Alpha Hydroxy,
Beta Hydroxy and Fruit Acids [10]. These treatment
modalities have been found to produce suboptimal results
and undesirable side effects when treating dark skins
phototypes [11, 12].
In the face of the challenges involved in treating melasma
* Corresponding author:
mpofanan@cput.ac.za (Nomakhosi Mpofana)
Published online at http://journal.sapub.org/ajdv
Copyright © 2014 Scientific & Academic Publishing. All Rights Reserved
via invasive means, therapists have recently directed their
energies towards exploring non-invasive channels of
treatment in Fitzpatrick skin type IV-VI [13, 1]. Goldman
[14] has gained the attention of skin therapists by offering a
treatment that is arguably safe, user-friendly and available
without a doctor’s prescription. Goldman [14] encourages
the use of light emitting diodes in patients with skin type
IV-VI.
The literature shows evidence of LED as a more recent
development which delivers narrow band, spectrally pure
light of a specific intensity wavelength and dose to achieve
clinically proven results [7]. LED is indicated to be a
non-thermal, non-coherent and quasi-monochromatic light
that has no down time on account of being a non-laser device
[15, 16]. LED was initially used to treat actinic keratosis and
superficial basal cell carcinomas, and has more recently been
used to treat visible photo ageing induced by excessive sun
exposure [3]. LED is seen as favourable for skin rejuvenation
because it minimises the risk of the side-effects that ablative
lasers present: LED systems are non–lasers, emitting no heat
which avoids any thermal effect on the skin [17].
In vitro studies evaluating the effect of LED on melasma
have shown success: results have indicated that LED (830nm,
850nm, 940nm) inhibits the production of Tyrosinase in
primary cultured melanocytes [18]. Other studies have found
LED to be effective in the improvement of sun damage,
(photorejuvenation) and pre-mature aging [14, 19, 17].
Although LED has shown much promise in theory, there is
still a degree of vagueness and uncertainty regarding its use
as a treatment option for melasma in skin type VI [6, 20, 21,
22]. On an empirical level, much research energy has been
channelled into the use of LED as treatment option. However
minimal research has been done to explore its response to