Effect of coagulant and flocculant addition scheme on the
treatment of dairy farm wastewater
Maen M. Husein and Ahmad Al-As’ad
ABSTRACT
Our group was approached by a manufacturer of treatment trains to recycle wastewater from dairy
farm manure. Company X treatment trains consist of microscreening, sedimentation and filtration
units attached to a reverse osmosis (RO) membrane. To enhance screening, a coagulant and a
flocculant are added to the stream feeding the microscreen. However, their customers experience
foaming on the microscreen as well as frequent fouling of the RO membranes. This study aimed to
identify the source of foaming and to optimize the performance of the treatment train. Results show
that interactions between the alum coagulant, the polymer flocculant and the contaminants are the
cause of foaming. Addition of silicon polymer antifoam A effectively reduced foaming, while
maintaining the same removal of total suspended solids (TSS) and total organic carbon (TOC).
Alternatively, we proposed a new reagent addition scheme which circumvents back-to-back addition
of the polymer flocculant and the alum coagulant. The proposed scheme resulted in significant
reduction in foaming and ∼50% increase in TSS and TOC removal, even at the 40% lower dose of the
cationic polymer. In addition to the economic benefit, a low concentration of left-over polymer
should alleviate the fouling of the RO membrane.
Maen M. Husein (corresponding author)
Ahmad Al-As’ad
Department of Chemical and Petroleum
Engineering,
University of Calgary,
Calgary,
AB T2N 1N4,
Canada
E-mail: maen.husein@ucalgary.ca
Key words | antifoam, coagulation, flocculation, membrane, total organic carbon, total suspended
solids
INTRODUCTION
Description of the problem
Company X builds trains targeting the treatment of waste-
water from livestock farming. The treated water may be
reused in the barn, while recovering raw manure and a con-
centrated fertilizer stream for land spreading. Their train
removes coarse and fine suspended solids, dissolved solids
and soluble organics. The treatment process consists of the
following major units: bulk solids removal, fine solids
removal, polishing filter, reverse osmosis (RO), final water
polishing and a reject water concentrator. Figure 1 is a
flow diagram showing the major units of the company X
treatment train. The coarse and fine solids removal units
include a microscreen followed by a sedimentation tank.
The wastewater stream feeding the microscreen from an
equalization tank is almost simultaneously impregnated
with alum as a coagulant and cationic polymer flocculants,
in order to promote large floc formation and separation on
the screens. The same chemicals also promote separation
of the fine solids in the clarifier. Of course, part of the
added flocculant will travel with the water stream as a
water-soluble polymer and will likely make it to the RO
unit. However, RO manufacturers warn against the use of
cationic polymer flocculants, since they interact with the
membrane material leading to low recovery ratios. In
addition, customers complain about frequent foam buildup
on the microscreen.
Foam adversely impacts the performance of the micro-
screen and the clarifier. Foam blocks screen openings and,
hence, hinders the flow of solid-free water and leads to
messy spills. Furthermore, foam traps air which causes
fine solids to float rather than settle in the clarifier unit.
271 © IWA Publishing 2015 Journal of Water Reuse and Desalination | 05.3 | 2015
doi: 10.2166/wrd.2015.070
Downloaded from https://iwaponline.com/jwrd/article-pdf/5/3/271/377460/jwrd0050271.pdf
by guest
on 30 December 2018