PERGAMON
Journal of
NEUROLIN(3UI$TICS
Journal of Neurolinguistics 14 (2001 ) 93-110
www.elsevier.com/locate/jneuroling
Dialectal variants of verbs in narratives
of African Americans with aphasia:
Some methodological considerations
Hanna K. Ulatowska and Gloria Streit Olness
University of Texas at Dallas
Abstract--A focus on African American Vernacular English (AAVE) verb use in narratives is
advantageous for examining the effects of dialect in aphasia. The inherent variability in
speakers' use of dialect features is discussed. Verb morpho-syntax is examined in speakers of
AAVE who have aphasia, and compared to that of African American normal controls. Dialect
features were preserved despite the presence of aphasia, although there was variability in
performance that could not readily be attributed to code-switching. While individuals with less
mild aphasia used fewer AAVE verb forms in this sample, they also produced shorter
narratives. The challenges of research in this area are discussed, and strategies are suggested
for future efforts.
Key words: African Americans, dialect, aphasia, verb system, narratives
Introduction
The current article proposes certain key methodological issues for the study of dialectal
manifestations among African Americans with aphasia. Points for consideration are
drawn from dialectal and clinical studies, in combination with qualitative analysis of an
extensive data set of personal narratives produced by African Americans with aphasia, and
African-American normal controls.
To our knowledge, there have been no systematic studies of dialectal features in the
discourse of African-American adults with aphasia. Early work in this area (e.g.,
Anderson & Ulatowska, 1975) was performed within a traditional clinical fi'amework of
repetition, reading, and writing tasks, for purposes of differential diagnosis.
Consideration of dialect in discourse would offer the opportunity to explore the
robustness of ethnic dialect features among African Americans who have aphasia, in their
very context of use. Not only would this offer insights on the relative complexity of the
various features of Afi-ican American Vernacular English (AAVE) in natural discourse
contexts, but also on the clinical issues important in working with individuals with
aphasia who speak an AAVE dialect. A logical first step in any such endeavor would be
to plan methodological approaches and anticipate potential complications or pitfalls in
0911-6044/01/$ - see front matter © 2001 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd.
PI/: S0911-6044(01)00010-0