Journal of Global Positioning Systems (2002)
Vol. 1, No. 2: 85-95
GPS Attitude Determination Reliability Performance Improvement
Using Low Cost Receivers
Chaochao Wang and Gérard Lachapelle
Department of Geomatics Engineering, University of Calgary
Received: 13 October 2002 / Accepted: 4 December 2002
Abstract. This paper describes different methods to
improve reliability of attitude estimation using low cost
GPS receivers. Previous work has shown that low cost
receiver attitude determination systems are more
susceptible to measurement errors, such as multipath,
phase center offsets, and cycle slips. In some cases, these
error sources lead to severely erroneous attitude estimates
and/or to a lower availability. The reliability control in
the attitude determination becomes imperative to users, as
most attitude applications require a high level of
reliability.
The three methods tested herein to improve reliability are
the use of a high data rate, fixed angular constraints, and
a quality control algorithm implemented with a Kalman
filter. The use of high rate measurements improves error
detection as well as ambiguity fixing time. Fixed angular
constraints in a multi-antenna attitude system is effective
to reject incorrect solutions during the ambiguity
resolution phase of the process. Utilizing a Kalman filter
with a high data rate, e.g. 10 Hz, not only increases
reliability through an increase of information, but also
can improve accuracy and availability. The simultaneous
utilization of the above methods significantly improves
reliability, as demonstrated through a series of hardware
simulations and field tests. The low cost receiver type
selected is the CMC Allstar receiver equipped with a
commercially available low cost antenna.
Finally, the use of statistically reliability measures,
namely internal and external reliability measures, shows
the inherent limitations of a low cost system and the need
to either use better antennas and/or external aiding in the
form of low cost sensors.
Key words: GPS, Attitude Determination, Low Cost
Receiver
1 Introduction
Multi-antenna GPS systems provide a high accuracy
attitude solution without error drift over time [e.g., Lu
1994]. The performance of GPS attitude determination is
a function of receiver firmware, satellite geometry,
antenna carrier phase stability, multipath rejection ability
and inter-antenna distances. With advances in GPS
receiver technology, low cost receivers equipped with
phase lock loops that output precisely time-synchronized
carrier phase measurements are now available on the
market. The use of this grade of GPS receiver for attitude
determination has proven feasible [e.g., Hoyle et al.
2002]. However, it has been found that multipath,
antenna phase center offsets and cycle slips are major
error sources that mitigate the performance of low cost
receiver attitude solutions. In worst-case scenarios, these
errors severely affect the integrated carrier phase
measurements and lead to incorrect attitude estimates in
attitude determination. Therefore, the reliability of
attitude estimation becomes a major issue.
The objective of this paper is to investigate three
methodologies to improve the reliability performance of
attitude determination using low cost receivers. Three
different schemes, namely the use of high rate carrier
phase measurements, fixed angular constraints and a
Kalman filter with a statistical quality control system, are
used interactively to improve reliability. These schemes
are implemented in a high performance, open architecture
attitude determination software, namely HEADRT+
TM
,
for testing [e.g. Hoyle et al 2002]. The performances of
different methods are examined both in hardware
simulation mode and under field static and kinematic
conditions.