Buoyant Droplets on Functional Fibers
Rië lle de Ruiter,
†,∥
Jolet de Ruiter,
†,∥
Hü seyin Burak Eral,
†
Ciro Semprebon,
‡
Martin Brinkmann,
‡,§
and Frieder Mugele*
,†
†
Physics of Complex Fluids, Faculty of Science and Technology, University of Twente, P.O. Box 217, 7500 AE Enschede, The
Netherlands
‡
Dynamics of Complex Fluids, Max-Planck-Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization, Bunsenstrasse 10, D-37073 Gö ttingen,
Germany
§
Experimental Physics, Saarland University, 66123 Saarbrü cken, Germany
ABSTRACT: In the absence of gravity, the wetting of droplets on fibers
is characterized by the competition between an axisymmetric barrel
morphology engulfing the fiber and a symmetry-broken clamshell
morphology with the droplet sitting on the side of the fiber. In the
generic case of nonzero buoyancy the cylindrical symmetry of the barrel
morphology is broken, yet barrels and clamshells can still be
distinguished based on their different interfacial topologies being
multiply and simply connected, respectively. Next to contact angle and
droplet size the capillary length appears as a third parameter controlling
the droplet morphology. For droplets of variable size, contact angle and buoyancy are independently varied in experiments by use
of electrowetting and density mismatch. This approachtogether with the complementary numerical calculationsprovides
new insights into the gradual shifts of the stability limits in the presence of an external volume force. Overall, the parameter space
for stable clamshells is found to expand with increasing gravitational forces, gradually shrinking the regimes of stable barrels and
bistability. In addition, a new stability limit is introduced for the clamshell morphology related to a partial detachment of the
wetting liquid from the fiber, appearing toward higher droplet volumes.
■
INTRODUCTION
Droplets on fibers are widely observed in nature, for instance as
dew droplets on spider webs, grass, and pine needles, and in
traditional engineering applications such as cleaning of textiles.
1
More recently, inspired from nature’s way of collecting and
transporting dew droplets on spider webs, digital microfluidics
on a fiber
2,3
and bio-inspired fibers for water collection in fog
filters
4−6
have been developed. The accumulation of droplets
by directional transport is critical to these systems. It has largely
been achieved by tuning the fiber shape or inclination: on a
horizontal conical wire, the motion of an axisymmetric droplet
is driven by a gradient in Laplace pressure.
7,8
On an inclined
fiber, gravity is the driving force.
9,10
As generally observed
under partial wetting conditions contact angle hysteresis
hinders droplet motion. To overcome this problem, bio-
inspired fibers are produced mimicking the structure of spider
silk:
4−6
the so-called spindle knots have different surface
roughness than the connection elements, thus exerting an
additional driving force toward the knot due to the surface
energy gradient.
The equilibrium morphology of the droplet on the fiber
influences both its attachment to and its motion along the
fiber
3
due to the difference in adhesion and contact area. In the
absence of buoyancy, two competing droplet morphologies
exist: the rotationally symmetric pearl-like “barrel” structure
and the symmetry-broken “clamshell” that sits at the side of the
fiber. The former was described by Plateau
11
in the context of
the instabilities of liquid films covering cylindrical fibers; the
latter was first noted by Adam.
1
More generally, the two
morphologies can also be distinguished by their topology: the
liquid interface of the barrel is multiply connected while that of
the clamshell is simply connected. This aspect distinguishes the
wetting of fibers from other geometries with competing liquid
morphologies such as the wetting of stripes
12−14
and the Cassie
and Wenzel wetting state on structured surfaces.
15,16
The
morphology transition from the barrel state to the clamshell
state has been studied extensively.
17−20
These studies identified
the droplet volume and the wettability of the fiber as key
control parameters. Only recently, we demonstrated the
existence of the inverse transition from the clamshell to the
barrel state and showed that reversible switching between both
morphologies is possible by tuning the wettability of the fiber
using electrowetting.
21
In our combined experimental and
numerical study, we identified the stability limits of both
morphologies for a density matched oil−water system.
Notwithstanding minor quantitative uncertainties, our study
clearly revealed fundamental differences between the barrel-to-
clamshell and the reverse clamshell-to-barrel transition: the
former is caused by a soft mode of the barrel morphology
Received: July 6, 2012
Revised: August 27, 2012
Published: August 27, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/Langmuir
© 2012 American Chemical Society 13300 dx.doi.org/10.1021/la302726z | Langmuir 2012, 28, 13300−13306