A New Paradigm for
Persistent Wide Area Surveillance
Lloyd L. Coulter,
Douglas A. Stow, Yu Hsin Tsai,
Christopher M. Chavis
Department of Geography
San Diego State University
San Diego, CA, USA
lcoulter@projects.sdsu.edu
stow@mail.sdsu.edu
cindyxtsai@gmail.com
cchavis10@ucsbalum.com
Richard W. McCreight
NEOS Ltd.
Prescott, AZ, USA
neos500@gmail.com
Christopher D. Lippitt
Grant W. Fraley
TerraPan Labs, LLC.
La Mesa, CA, USA
lippitt@terrapanlabs.com
fraley@terrapanlabs.com
Abstract— A novel and patent pending approach representing a
new paradigm for persistent wide area surveillance is presented.
As part of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) National
Center for Border Security and Immigration (BORDERS), San
Diego State University (SDSU) researchers have developed a
method for accurate and automated detection of people and
vehicles moving through remote border regions or other
uninhabited areas. Instead of imaging small areas at video frame
rates (as with traditional surveillance), the approach uses a
repeat pass, location-based image capture approach that trades
time for space and enables repetitive imaging of large areas at
lower repetition rates. Multiple targets may be detected and
tracked over large areas, compared to video monitoring which
focuses on small areas and often on individual targets previously
detected using other means. The approach utilizes high
frequency, repeat pass image collection (e.g., same imaging
stations every 15 minutes) with frame array cameras to monitor
large areas with a single aircraft and detect and locate objects
moving through uninhabited landscapes. High frequency
imaging from low-cost light aircraft is utilized to characterize the
expected brightness response of each patch of ground
corresponding to the ground resolution element of a pixel (3-inch
ground sampling distance for this study), and an anomaly
detection algorithm is used to detect subtle deviations from this
expected response. Once anomalies (i.e., objects that have
moved) are detected, small image chips (i.e., subsets) may be
transmitted wirelessly to command and control stations so that
the detection results may be visually verified in near real-time.
The detection algorithm utilizes unique change detection
thresholds per pixel, making the approach highly sensitive.
Initial test results indicate that 98% of people and 100% of
vehicles were correctly detected, with virtually no false detection
(only 12 pixels within 19 images 21 megapixel in size). SDSU
researchers, NEOS Ltd., and commercial partners are working to
build a prototype system to further test and demonstrate this
near real-time detection approach. This work is developed by the
National Center for Border Security and Immigration: A
Department of Homeland Security Science and Technology
Center of Excellence.
Keywords- wide area surveillance, change detection, airborne,
video, real-time, pattern-of-life, UAV, UAS, border security
I. INTRODUCTION
The U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agency is
responsible for securing the borders of the United States, and
the Border Patrol specifically is responsible for patrolling the
10,000 kilometers of Mexican and Canadian international
borders. Their general mission is to detect and prevent illegal
entry of people and/or goods into the United States. The Border
Patrol also performs a humanitarian mission, by rescuing
people lost in remote locations and exposed to harsh
environmental conditions. Since the terrorist attacks of
September 11, 2001, the focus of the Border Patrol has
expanded to include detection, apprehension and/or deterrence
of terrorists and terrorist weapons. It is not practical, however,
to closely monitor the tens of thousands of square kilometers of
open land within close proximity of the border using agents and
ground-based sensors alone. Airborne remote sensing offers the
potential to monitor expansive areas within the border region,
and identify activity of people/vehicles that has not been
detected by agents patrolling the border or by ground-based
sensors [1].
As part of the National Center for Border Security and
Immigration, researchers with the Center for Earth Systems
Analysis Research (CESAR) within the Department of
Geography at SDSU have developed a novel approach for
accurate and automated detection of people and vehicles
moving through remote border regions or other uninhabited
areas. This approach builds upon several years of experience
with precise multitemporal image registration and detailed
change detection. The people and vehicle detection approach
utilizes time series imagery for characterizing expected
scene/background response on a per-pixel basis, and then looks
for subtle brightness changes that deviate from the expected
response of each individual pixel. The general approach and
initial results were first described in Coulter et al. (2012) [1].
The objective of this paper is to provide further insights into
the characteristics and benefits of this time series change
detection approach, and to discuss the next steps in the
development and testing of the methodology.
978-1-4673-2709-1/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE 51