ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Medical and Psychosocial Complications Associated With
Method of Bladder Management After Traumatic Spinal
Cord Injury
Anne P. Cameron, MD, Lauren P. Wallner, MPH, Martin B. Forchheimer, MPP, J. Quentin Clemens, MD,
Rodney L. Dunn, MS, Gianna Rodriguez, MD, David Chen, MD, John Horton III, MD, Denise G. Tate, PhD
ABSTRACT. Cameron AP, Wallner LP, Forchheimer MB,
Clemens JQ, Dunn RL, Rodriguez G, Chen D, Horton J III,
Tate DG. Medical and psychosocial complications associated
with method of bladder management after traumatic spinal cord
injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2011;92:449-56.
Objectives: To determine the relationships between bladder
management method and medical complications (renal calculi
or decubitus ulcers), number of hospital days, and psychosocial
factors. We hypothesized that indwelling catheterization would
be associated with more complications, more hospitalizations,
and worse psychosocial outcomes compared with other bladder
management methods.
Design: Inception cohort study.
Setting: Model spinal cord injury (SCI) centers funded by
the National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research
from 1973 to 2005.
Participants: Persons with new traumatic SCI (N=24,762)
enrolled in the National SCI Database entire data set forms I
and II. Patients were stratified according to the bladder man-
agement method recorded at each time of data collection into 1
of 4 groups as follows: indwelling catheterization, spontaneous
voiding, condom catheterization, and intermittent catheteriza-
tion. Those who reported no management method or errors in
reporting were excluded (n=1564).
Interventions: Not applicable.
Main Outcome Measures: Medical complications, includ-
ing pressure ulcer number and grade of worst ulcer, kidney
stones, and hospitalizations, as well as psychosocial factors
(satisfaction with life, perceived health status, societal partici-
pation), were stratified by bladder management method. Re-
sults were adjusted for level and completeness of neurologic
injury and other confounding and modifying factors.
Results: Compared with other forms of bladder manage-
ment, use of an indwelling catheter was associated with more
pressure ulcers and longer and more hospitalizations for all
causes and urology-specific causes. Indwelling catheter use
was associated with the lowest levels of participation, but
similar satisfaction with life and perceived health status.
Conclusions: Indwelling catheterization was associated with
more medical complications and lower levels of participation
than other bladder management methods, but more research is
required to ascertain the causality of these complications.
Key Words: Catheters, indwelling; Pressure ulcer; Quality
of life; Rehabilitation; Spinal cord injuries; Urinary bladder,
neurogenic.
© 2011 by the American Congress of Rehabilitation
Medicine
W
ITH IMPROVED MEDICAL CARE, persons with SCI
are surviving at 70% to 92% of average life expectancy.
1
Therefore, the choice of bladder management and its impact on
long-term medical outcomes and quality of life have become
increasingly important.
Published guidelines regard clean or aseptic IC as the
criterion standard for bladder management if the patient is
able and willing to perform the task.
2-4
Use of IC typically
has been associated with fewer bladder calculi,
5
urinary tract
infections, and urethral complications
6-10
and a lower risk
for bladder cancer
11,12
than observed with indwelling cath-
eterization. However, some studies have found little differ-
ence in complications between various bladder management
approaches,
13-15
and a recent Cochrane review
16
of catheter
management in patients with neurogenic bladder could not
find evidence robust enough to suggest one form of man-
agement instead of another.
Few studies have focused on the relationships of bladder
management to psychosocial well-being in patients with
SCI. These studies also often are limited by small sample
size, inadequate outcome measures, and sample bias. A
number of investigators have studied factors leading to
psychosocial adjustment after SCI, with some focusing on
losses related to bladder function, satisfaction, complica-
tions, and mortality.
17-19
Most studies found depression to
be related to urologic complications. Hicken et al
20
reported
improved life satisfaction in patients with SCI who voided
without the use of devices; however, other investigators
have found little difference in patient satisfaction with an
From the Departments of Urology (Cameron, Wallner, Clemens), Epidemiology
(Wallner, Dunn), and Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation (Forchheimer, Rodriguez,
Tate), University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI; Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago,
Chicago, IL (Chen); and University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA (Horton).
Supported by the National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research
(grant no. H133N060032).
A commercial party having a direct financial interest in the results of the research
supporting this article has conferred or will confer a financial benefit on the author or
one or more of the authors. Clemens is an investigator and consultant with Pfizer and
Lilly, a consultant with investment interest at Merck, and a proctor at Medtronic.
Reprint requests to Anne P. Cameron, MD, 2875 Taubman Center, 1500 E Medical
Center Dr, Ann Arbor, MI, 48169, e-mail: annepell@med.umich.edu.
Published online January 31, 2011 at www.archives-pmr.org
0003-9993/11/9203-00100$36.00/0
doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2010.06.028
List of Abbreviations
ASIA American Spinal Cord Injury Association
CHART-SF Craig Handicap Assessment and Reporting
Technique Short-Form
CI confidence interval
IC intermittent catheterization
NSCIDB National Spinal Cord Injury Database
OR odds ratio
SCI spinal cord injury
SWLS Satisfaction With Life Scale
449
Arch Phys Med Rehabil Vol 92, March 2011