ABSTRACT. The purpose of our article is to present
a qualitative empirical study from the ethical view-
point. It aims at the theoretical conceptualization
concerning the managers’ decision-making of per-
sonnel dismissals in downsizing organizations. First we
present and seek to motivate our research task. The
importance of real business ethical issues as a starting
point of business ethics research is emphasized.
Second the main normative ethical theories and
ethical decision-making models are presented. These
form the loose framework for describing and inter-
preting research interviews. After this the empirical
findings are set forth. This part suggests that the
managers explain the dismissals from different
decision-making roles emphasizing different ethical
orientation. The roles are called a rational and an
independent manager, a marionette and an emotional
individual. Our study suggests that the role of
empathy in morality reveals an interesting and a
necessary research topic for business ethics research.
The working career of the industrial society is
considered full-time, life-long and permanent.
However, this ideal seems to be in transition at
the moment. Individuals can no longer trust on
permanent jobs and security. Organizational
downsizing defined as intentional and planned
elimination of jobs and positions seems to be the
unavoidable accompaniment of current business
trends. Since the eighties downsizing has become
popular in western societies (Cameron, 1994).
There were quite a few companies that did not
downsize at all during the 1980s and 1990s.
Feldman and Leana (1994) describe that layoffs
are no longer abstract business phenomena that
occur in someone else’s industry or hometown.
There is actually no one who does not know
someone who has been laid off or has not had
at least some anxiety about the job security.
Among those who lose or are in danger to lose
their jobs are also groups which earlier were
thought to be safe from economic uncertainty,
such as managers and specialists (Kanter, 1989;
Tichy and Devanna, 1990). Despite the current
economic recovery that seems to be occurring,
massive downsizing continues apace at one major
firm after another. Downsizing is probably one
of the most disruptive and dramatic type of
organizational change which many managers are
likely to experience nowadays. A poorly executed
downsizing can traumatize a company for years
and lead to unexpected results (Drew, 1994).
However, knowledge concerning managing
downsizing and reducing staff is not very
common. Most attention in managerial literature
Downsizing and Ethics of
Personnel Dismissals –
Anna-Maija Lämsä
The Case of Finnish Managers Tuomo Takala
Journal of Business Ethics 23: 389–399, 2000.
© 2000 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Anna-Maija Lämsä is a researcher and lecturer of man-
agement and organizations at the University of
Jyväskylä, School of Business and Economics in
Finland. She has publications in International Journal
of Entrepreneurship, Nordic Journal of Education,
and Electronic Journal of Business and Organiza-
tion. She has published in Publications from the School
of Business and Economics, University of Jyväskylä. She
has also published several articles concerning change
management and development of business education in
professional journals and books in Finland.
Tuomo Takala is a professor of management and organi-
zations at the University of Jyväskylä in Finland. His
main research interests are business ethics and leadership.
He is the editor-in-chief of Electronic Journal of
Business and Organization Ethics . He has published
e.g. in Scandinavian Journal of Management ,
Journal of Business Ethics , European Journal of
Marketing, International Journal of Social
Economics and Corporate Communications – An
International Journal.