Research Article
Analytical and Numerical Investigation of Lacing Wire Damage
Induced Mistuning in Turbine Blade Packet
Mangesh S. Kotambkar and Animesh Chatterjee
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Visvesvaraya National Institute of Technology, Nagpur 440010, India
Correspondence should be addressed to Mangesh S. Kotambkar; mskotamb@yahoo.com
Received 15 August 2014; Accepted 12 November 2014; Published 9 December 2014
Academic Editor: Abdelkrim Khelif
Copyright © 2014 M. S. Kotambkar and A. Chatterjee. Tis is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons
Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
Investigations of modal parameters for a mistuned packet of turbine blades due to lacing wire damage are reported using analytical
and numerical studies with a simplifed model. Te turbine blade is assumed to be an Euler-Bernoulli beam connected with a lacing
wire which is modeled as a mass less linear elastic spring. Tus, the blade is considered as a continuous system and lacing wire as a
discrete system. Te analytical results using Eigen value analysis are compared with numerical results obtained using commercial
fnite element package. In real life situation, though not reported in the literature, it is the failure of lacing wire that occurs quite
ofen compared to the turbine blade and acts as precursor to the subsequent blade damage if it goes undetected. Terefore, studying
the modal parameters of the grouped turbine blades in the context of lacing wire failure becomes important. Te efect of variation
of lacing wire location and stifness indicative of damage resulting in the loss of stifness on modal parameters is investigated. Te
study reveals a lot of fundamental understandings pertaining to dynamic behavior of grouped blades compared to the stand-alone
blade under the infuence of damaged lacing wire.
1. Introduction
Turbine is the most widely used prime movers in power
plants, turbo engines, and compressors in aircrafs and also in
auxiliary turbo driven equipment such as turbo pumps. Tur-
bine blade vibration and its failure under high cycle fatigue
is an important area of research studies due to its critical
applications. Te blade failures are mainly due to resonant
stresses when one of the natural frequencies of blade-disk
system matches the nozzle passing frequency. Design of these
turbomachine blades thus critically depends on accurate
understanding of the blade vibration characteristics under
varied operating conditions. However, modeling and analysis
of turbine blade vibration becomes quite complex due to
continuously tapered and twisted cross-section and blade to
blade dynamic coupling through lacing wire or shroud rings.
Almost 50% of low pressure steam turbine blade failure
is due to fatigue caused by vibration [1]. A turbine blade
is a complex geometry having aerofoil shape with varying
width and thickness along its length. Most of the early
research works have been based on simplifed cantilever beam
modeling where efects of root fexibility and crack in the
stand-alone blade have been studied [2–9]. However, the
dynamics of grouped blades is even more complex than a free
stand-alone blade.
Rao [10] has summarized the vibration behavior of
turbine blades studied numerically and experimentally in
the past in his book. In the recent past, research on turbine
blade has focused on blades in a packet. Tere are many
advantages of packeted turbine blades connected with lacing
wire. For instance, resultant natural frequency increases
with the number of blades in group and stifening due to
interconnection of blades with the lacing wire.
Smith [11] has made signifcant contribution in deter-
mining the group frequencies and mode shapes of a blade
packet. He also discussed the use of lacing wire in turbine
blade groups. Ellington and McCallion [12] simplifed Smith’s
analysis by using fnite diference calculus to the special case
of blade group with a tie wire which joins the blade tips
together.
Prohl [13] used lumped parameter approach by consider-
ing series of concentrated masses and concentrated stifness
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Advances in Acoustics and Vibration
Volume 2014, Article ID 164638, 16 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/164638