APPLICATION OF SENSORY, NUTRACEUTICAL AND GENETIC
TECHNIQUES TO CREATE A QUALITY PROFILE OF ANCIENT
APPLE CULTIVARS
D. DONNO
1
, G.L. BECCARO, M.G. MELLANO, D. TORELLO MARINONI, A.K. CERUTTI, S. CANTERINO and
G. BOUNOUS
Department of Arboriculture, Università degli Studi di Torino, Via Leonardo da Vinci 44, Grugliasco (TO) 10095, Italy
1
Corresponding author. TEL:
+39-011-670-8821; FAX: +39-011-670-8658;
EMAIL: dario.donno@unito.it
Received for Publication August 3, 2011
Accepted for Publication January 16, 2012
doi:10.1111/j.1745-4557.2012.00442.x
ABSTRACT
With the diffusion of commercial apple varieties since the second half of the last
century, hundreds of different local cultivars rapidly disappeared from orchards in
Italy, and the particular quality attributes of these fruits are still at risk of being lost
today. The aim of this research was to use sensory, nutritional and genetic techniques
in order to define the overall quality of fruits from ancient apple cultivars grown in
Northern Italy. Cluster analysis arranged the 10 genotypes into five groups; in most
cases, the analyzed cultivars demonstrated higher sensory and nutritional qualities
than the control (Golden Delicious cv). The cultivars showed higher values of total
polyphenolic compounds and a stronger antioxidant activity. The vitamin C content
also differed from the control. The sensory analysis, performed by the Fruit Tasters
Italian Organization, was an effective characterization tool and genetic analysis
further helped to characterize the identity of these interesting cultivars.
PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS
The characterization and valorization of old apple cultivars are essential to avoid loss
of potentially useful germplasm. The reduction of biodiversity of cultivars found in
agriculture could lead to problems such as higher susceptibility to widespread out-
breaks of plant diseases and pests, and at the same time, the loss of precious source of
nutrients. The conservation of apple biodiversity is valuable in order to maintain the
gene pool of the species and to introduce superior quality traits into apple-breeding
programs.
INTRODUCTION
The apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) is one of the most impor-
tant fruit tree crops in temperate countries. The species
belongs to the genus Malus, originating in Asia Minor, and was
later introduced into Europe and Egypt. The genus Malus
spread spontaneously in the northern hemisphere, between 30
and 60° latitude.Total world production was about 55*10
6
tons
in 2008 (FAOSTAT 2010,http://faostat.fao.org/default.aspx).
Until the middle of the last century in Italy, as in many
other fruit-producing countries, hundreds of different culti-
vars were grown. However, in the 1960s, with the diffusion of
commercial varieties because of orchard specialization, the
local germplasm lost importance and began to be forgotten
by growers and consumers. Many ancient cultivars were
gradually replaced by commercial varieties and the Italian
fruit-growing scene underwent significant change (Bounous
and De Guarda 2008). Indeed, more than 70% of orchards
only have one cultivar, the commercial variety Golden Deli-
cious. The fruits of the ancient cultivars were characterized by
very unconventional quality traits, such as different fruit
shapes and skin color, and varying nutritional values and
organoleptic traits (such as crispness, juiciness and flavor)
(Bounous et al. 2006). For this reason, the ancient cultivars
should be preserved in order to maintain both biodiversity
and the historical and cultural links that they represent.
In the last 10 years, various conservation and development
research programs studying the local fruit germplasm have
Journal of Food Quality ISSN 1745-4557
1 Journal of Food Quality •• (2012) ••–•• © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.