1
© South African Professional Society on the Abuse of Children: ISSN 1562-1383
Child Abuse Research: A South African Journal 2018, 19(2): 1-13
Reflections on parenting practices that impact child-
rearing in a low-income community
Naiema Taliep
South African Medical Research Council-University of South Africa Violence, Injury and Peace
Research Unit, Tygerberg; Institute for Social and Health Sciences, University of South Africa
E-mail: naiema.taliep@mrc.ac.za
Ghouwa Ismail
Institute for Social and Health Sciences, University of South Africa; South African Medical
Research Council-University of South Africa Violence, Injury and Peace Research Unit, Tygerberg
E-mail: ghouwa.ismail@mrc.ac.za
Neziswa Titi
South African Medical Research Council-University of South Africa Violence, Injury and Peace
Research Unit, Tygerberg
E-mail: neziswa.titi@mrc.ac.za
Parenting plays an important role in the socialisation of children and youth, and ineffective parenting has been
associated with multiple negative social and health outcomes among young people. Any attempt to design
contextually relevant multi-system interventions to improve parenting practices and reduce negative child and
adolescent outcomes must be based on an understanding of how contextual factors influence parenting
practices. A phenomenological reflective lifeworld approach was utilised to explore parents’ lived experiences
of multiple intersecting socio-demographic factors and community social processes that impact on their
parenting practices. This study was framed by social disorganisation theory rooted within an ecological
framework. Using purposive sampling, data was collected from 47 parents comprising local residents and
stakeholders (36 focus group participants and 7 individual interview participants) in a low-income community in
Cape Town, South Africa, Thematic analysis of the qualitative data revealed various socio-demographic factors
characteristic of community disorder that intersect with parenting and contributes to neglectful parenting. These
factors include socio-economic disadvantage that leads to parental stress for predominantly single parent
families, and a lack of formal and informal social control compounded by community disorder. This highlights
the need for multi-level parenting interventions that address both community structural and social processes.
Keywords: parenting practices; South Africa; family structure; social disorganisation theory
INTRODUCTION
Parenting plays an important role in the socialisation of children and adolescents. Ineffective parenting
has been associated with multiple negative social and health outcomes, including child and adolescent
negative emotionality (Haller & Chassin, 2011); delinquency, violence, anti-social behaviour (Cooper,
De Lannoy & Rule, 2015); substance abuse problems (see Pears, Capaldi & Owen, 2007) and various
health disparities (see Ventura & Birch, 2008). A large corpus of research focuses on the consequences of
negative parenting practices and the impact and outcomes of parenting interventions within contexts
outside of Africa (see Power et al, 2013; Scott et al, 2014). Little research has been done on parental
perceptions regarding contextual factors that impact parenting practices within low-income communities
within South Africa. Given the complexities and dynamic nature of family structures, and compositional
features and community social processes within a South African context, one cannot generalise from one
community to the next, much less from other contexts to a South African context. Attempts to design
contextually relevant multi-system interventions focusing on improving parenting practices and reducing
negative child and adolescent outcomes must be based on an understanding of how the aforementioned
features and processes influence parenting. Thus, in light of this paucity in the South African context, the
need exists to explore contextual factors that affect parenting practices within low-income South African
communities that will inform contextually relevant interventions.
Approximately 85,000 children (0.5%) in South Africa are reared in a total of 61,000 child-headed
households (Meintjies, Hall & Sambu, 2015), which has been ascribed to challenges such as HIV/AIDS
and violence (UNICEF, 2013). A child-headed household can be regarded as one in which a child (under
18 years) within the household has assumed the primary responsibility for the household due to parental
or caregiver absence or when parents or primary caregivers are present, but are unable to provide the
Open Rubric