Electric Power Systems Research 56 (2000) 1 – 8
Dead zone phenomenon in distance relaying of overhead
transmission lines
Dus ˇko D. Bekut*, Goran S. S venda, Vladimir C. Strezoski
Faculty of Engineering, Institute for Power and Electronic Engineering, Uniersity of Noi Sad, Fruskogorska 11, 21000 Noi Sad,
Serbia, Yugoslaia
Received 26 July 1998; received in revised form 3 January 1999; accepted 26 February 1999
Abstract
This paper refers to the distance protection of overhead transmission line. The phenomenon of ‘dead zones’ in distance relay
operation is established. This phenomenon consists of a segment of an overhead line, inside the distance relay reach, where the
relay can not detect a fault. The nature of the dead zone phenomenon is the most complex when the distance protection of
mutually coupled lines is considered. Thus, clarifying the nature and proposing measures for elimination of dead zones from
distance protection are main objectives of this paper. A simple example is considered to get a qualitative insight into the dead zone
appearance. Presented considerations are illustrated by example belonging to the actual power system of Yugoslavia. © 2000
Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Distance relaying; Distance relay dead zone; Mutually coupled lines
www.elsevier.com/locate/epsr
1. Introduction
The basic principle of the distance protection is based
on the linear dependence between the value of the
impedance measured by the distance relay (measured
impedance
1
) and the distance between locations of the
relay and the fault [1,2]. Such a linearity is valid
exclusively for solid faults which have occurred inside
the first protective zone of a distance relay protecting a
two-terminal line (the first protective zone belongs to
the same line on which the corresponding relay is
located). In other cases, this dependence is not linear.
The most important cases in which such non-linearities
occur are:
1. The fault at the first protective zone of a distance
relay is accompanied by a resistance. If it occurs, the
non-linearity culminates, when the line is double-
side infeed and the short-circuit power in the part of
the system behind the distance relay is ‘small’ and
the short circuit power in the part of the system at
the other side of the line is ‘large’. The non-linearity
is more significant when lines are close and the
coupling is partial. Very interesting and important
situations are those when variations of the fault
location at one line imply changes of both magni-
tude and direction of currents in other mutually
coupled lines.
2. Faults at three (multi) terminal lines are considered.
3. The fault and the corresponding distance relay do
not belong to the same line. That is the case when
higher protective zones (the second and the third
one) of distance relays are considered. In such a
situation, the value of the relay measured impedance
significantly depends on the value of the infeed
factor
2
. This value does not depend linearly on the
fault location. Therefore, dead zones appear more
frequently at the higher protective zones than at the
first one.
The material presented in this paper is part of the investigations
encompassed by the project for the EPS JP Elektrovojvodina Power
Company, Novi Sad, Serbia, Yugoslavia, 1996.
* Corresponding author.
1
‘Measured impedance’ means the impedance magnitude, its resis-
tance or reactance.
2
The ‘infeed factor’ is defined as the ratio of the faulted line
current and the current of the line where the considered relay is
located.
0378-7796/00/$ - see front matter © 2000 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.
PII:S0378-7796(00)00078-X