Clinical Neuropsychiatry (2017) 14, 4, 257-262
Comparing interpersonal Counseling and antidepressant treatment in
primary Care patients with anxious and nonanxious major depression disorder:
a randomized Control trial
Mario Altamura, Salvatore Iuso, Grazia Terrone, Angela Balzotti, Rafaella Carnevale, Stefania Malerba,
antonello Bellomo, annamaria petito
Abstract
Objective: Comorbid anxiety symptoms are common in patients with major depressive disorders and contribute to
poorer response to both psychotherapeutic and pharmacologic depression treatments. The aim of the present study was
to compare the efcacy of Interpersonal Counseling (IPC) with antidepressant treatments in primary care patients with
anxious and nonanxious major depression.
Method: Participants with depression symptoms, enrolled from primary care sites, were randomized to 8 weeks
treatment with either IPC or Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs). Participants were eligible if they met
criteria for nonpsychotic Major Depression Disorder (MDD) based on the criteria of Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders (5th edition). A minimum Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAM-D) score of ≥8 was also required.
Using the Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale (HAM-A, score > 14) patients were classifed as anxious or nonanxious.
Rates of remission (defned as HAM-D score of ≤7 over 3 consecutive weeks) and change from baseline in anxiety and
depression symptoms were compared between patients with anxious depression and those with nonanxious depression.
Results: In the nonanxious subgroup the proportion of patients who achieved remission was no signifcant in the IPC
group compared with the SSRI group (77.78% vs 72.73%; P= 0.9). The proportion of anxious patients who achieved
remission was signifcantly higher in the IPC group compared with the SSRI group (100% vs 87.5%; P<0.0001).
Analyses based on continuous scores indicated a signifcant improvement over the 8 weeks in depressive symptoms
in both the nonanxious and the anxious subgroups and between the initial and fnal scores in anxiety symptoms in the
anxious subgroup.
Conclusions: IPC can be as efective as medications for the treatment of mild to moderate major depression and is an
efective treatment option for the proportion of patients with MDD who have prominent anxious symptoms. These results
indicate the need to consider diferent strategies for the management of patients with anxious depression in primary care
Key words: interpersonal psychotherapy, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, depression, anxiety, primary care
Declaration of interest: none
Mario Altamura ¹*, Salvatore Iuso ¹, Grazia Terrone ², Angela Balzotti ¹, Rafaella Carnevale ¹, Stefania Malerba¹,
antonello Bellomo ¹, annamaria petito ¹
¹ Department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine, Psychiatry Unit, University of Foggia, Foggia, Italy
² Department of Humanities, Literature, Cultural Heritage, University of Foggia, Foggia, Italy
Corresponding author
mario altamura
Department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine, Psychiatry Unit, University of Foggia
Tel./fax: +39 01139/0881732285.
E-mail address: m_altamura@virgilio.it
Submitted May 2017, Accepted July 2017
© 2017 Giovanni Fioriti Editore s.r.l. 257
Introduction
There is evidence that most patients with major
depression (MDD) seen in primary care sufer from
concurrent subsyndromal symptoms of anxiety (that
is, depressed patients who do not meet the diagnostic
criteria for anxiety disorders) (Clayton et al. 1991;
Fava et al. 2006, 2008). Earlier studies have shown
that the prevalence of anxiety symptoms (quantifed
on a rating scale) among outpatients with MDD was
in the range of 44%–46% (Fava et al. 2004). A more
recent survey focusing on the prevalence of comorbid
anxiety symptoms in depression has shown that an
impressive 87% of elderly individuals with MDD
living in the community also had subthreshold anxiety
symptoms (Braam et al. 2014). Numerous studies have
reported that patients with anxious depression (MDD
plus anxiety symptoms) have greater illness severity
(Fava et al. 2006), an increased risk of suicidality,
lower quality of life (Seo et al. 2011), and poorer
response to antidepressant medications (Flint and Rifat
1997, Russel et al. 2001, Davidson et al. 2002, Fava
et al. 2008, Ionescu et al. 2014) and psychotherapeutic
interventions (Frank et al. 2000) than depressed
patients without anxiety symptoms. This evidence has
led to the introduction of a new diagnostic “anxious
distress” specifer in the Diagnostic and Statistical
manual 5
th
Edition (DSM-5) (American Psychiatric