Unsaturated Soils: Advances in Geo-Engineering – Toll et al. (eds)
© 2008Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-47692-8
Stability of a tailings dam considering the hydro-mechanical behaviour
of tailings and climate factors
M.T. Zandarín & L. Oldecop
Instituto de Investigaciones Antisísmicas ‘‘Ing. Aldo Bruschi’’, Facultad de Ingeniería,
Universidad Nacional de San Juan, San Juan, Argentina
R.R. Pacheco
Departamento de Química. Facultad de Ciencias. Universitat de Girona. Campus Montilvi, Girona, Spain
ABSTRACT: Tailings storage facilities are complex geotechnical structures. The present paper focuses on
the study of a case-history, a tailing dam from the nickel industry from Cuba, with the objective of gaining
knowledge about the geotechnical behaviour of such structures. The dam was modelled by means of a coupled
hydro-mechanical finite element formulation. Due to the low permeability of tailings, the phreatic levels in the
deposit remain high during and after its construction. Steady-state flow regime would be reached only after
several decades after closure. Moreover, capillary rise causes the degree of saturation to stay high in the whole
storage. Under the action of rain storms, phreatic levels rise quickly due to the presence of capillary water. At
the end of the storm, phreatic levels fall slowly because of the low hydraulic conductivity. The results of the
analysis show that the stability of the dam strongly depends on its hydraulic operation.
1 INTRODUCTION
Tailings storage facilities are complex geotechnical
structures. They are commonly built by the discharge
of slurry within an impoundment. Tailings are fine-
grained non-plastic materials. Their permeability is
low and unsaturated phenomena play a significant role
in their behaviour. A number of factors may influ-
ence the stability of tailings dams, such as the pluvial
regime, evaporation, capillary rise, construction rate,
drainage, consolidation and rain storms. The present
paper focuses on the study of a case-history, with the
aim of identifying which of those factors are relevant
for the structural safety of tailings dams.
The tailings dam studied is one of the facilities at
Pedro Sotto Alba nickel mine, located in the province
of Moa, in the southeast of Cuba. The impound-
ment is located on a low lying flood plain in the
south bank of Moa River (Figure 1a). It is founded
on alluvial sediments of quaternary age, underlain
by stiff clays and cretaceous ultramafic serpentine
(Figure 1b). (Chalkley et al. 2002; Greenaway et al.
2002).
The climate at the site is tropical. Temperatures vary
between 23
◦
C and 27
◦
C and the annual average rainfall
is 2830 mm. The rainfall intensity can reach between
2 and 3 mm per minute, for rainfall events with 5 to
20 minutes duration, having a period of recurrence of
100 years (Moya, 1998). Two extraordinary rainstorms
occurred in 1996 and 1998 (Chalkley et al. 2002). The
first lasted 48 h with a total rain volume of 722 mm and
a maximum intensity of 190 mm in 90 minutes. The
second lasted 12 h with a 690 mm total precipitation.
The annual average evaporation is 2296 mm.
Figure 2 shows the monthly average rainfall and
evaporation at the site.
The operation of the facility began in 1970. Tail-
ings were discharged in slurry form behind a laterite
embankment built in stages, applying the upstream
construction method. The mean rise rate of the
impoundment was about a half metre per year until
1987. The facility had a system of decant pipelines to
allow the drainage of the excess water accumulated in
the decant pond.
The section 1-1 shown in Figure 1b experienced a
number of episodes of slope instability. Such episodes
involved the release of important amounts of tailings
covering the flood plain of the Moa River and Los
Lirios Creek. Tailing relicts can be found even in the
opposite bank (north) of Moa River, indicating that at
some time the slurry flow was large enough to cross the
main channel of the river. During the 1990 s a number
of works were undertaken in order to rehabilitate the
facility (Chalkley et al. 2002, Greenaway et al. 2002).
In the present work, section 1-1 was modelled with
the objective of gaining knowledge about the influence
925