© John Z. Wee, 2021 | doi : 10. 1163 / 9789004443143 _ 015
Chapter 13
A Systemic Etiology of Sicknesses from Ancient
Iraq: Organ Systems and the Functional Holism
of the Babylonian Body
John Z. Wee
Abstract
From the Late Achaemenid city of Uruk comes a single cuneiform document de-
scribed here as a Systemic Etiology, which attributes to various sicknesses their
origins ‘from’ four ancient organ systems – psychic, alimentary, respiratory, and
excretory-reproductive – that bear remarkable resemblance to classifications in mod-
ern biology. Features of such a functional holism may already be detected, in vary-
ing degrees, elsewhere in the Mesopotamian medical literature. The striking manner
in which the Etiology re-categorizes certain sicknesses, nonetheless, illustrates how
holisms do not organize their constituents in a disinterested fashion, or group them
together merely on the basis of previously known characteristics, but can also reframe
perspectives in ways that impose new meanings on individual constituents’ identities.
Many hundreds of cuneiform medical tablets from ancient Iraq compel us to
rethink the ways we write ancient histories of medicine. In contrast to medical
manuscripts of papyrus, parchment, or paper that often survive today in rela-
tively late copies, these highly durable clay tablets from Mesopotamia come to
us from much closer to their milieus of composition, transmission, and usage,
allowing us to envision probable scenarios in which such documents were ac-
tually employed in historical contexts. While the cuneiform materials open up
new kinds of agenda beyond what have been considered in the study of other
ancient medical cultures, there are also issues on which they are particularly
intractable – among which is the question of how individual sicknesses and
bodily constituents were assigned to separate categories that, when viewed in
relation to each other, informed one’s understanding of the whole.
Explanatory discourses in Greek or Chinese treatises, for example, have ar-
ticulated or clearly implied well-defined positions and principles on general
topics like nutrition, the environment, medicaments, or categories of sickness.
9789004443082_Thumiger_text_proof-02.indb 318 9789004443082_Thumiger_text_proof-02.indb 318 24/09/2020 6:37:57 pm 24/09/2020 6:37:57 pm