978-1-4673-0878-6/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE
April 19-22, 2012
Cappadocia, Turkey 24
TURKISH PHARMACEUTICALS TRACK & TRACE SYSTEM
Serap Malc ¸ok Altunkan, Alper Yasemin,
˙
Ismail Taha Aykac ¸, and Elgin Akpınar
T¨ urkiye
˙
Ilac ¸ ve Tıbbi Cihaz Kurumu
S¨ o˘ g¨ ut¨ oz¨ u Mahallesi 2176. Sokak. No:5 P.K. 06520 C ¸ ankaya/ANKARA
phone: +90 (312) 2183000, fax: +90 (312) 2183460, email: its@iegm.gov.tr
web: http://www.iegm.gov.tr/
ABSTRACT
The Turkish ’Pharmaceuticals Track & Trace System’ (as
˙
Ilac ¸ Takip Sistemi or abbreviated as ’
˙
ITS’ in Turkish) is an
implementation of Track & Trace methodologies in the phar-
maceutical area.
˙
ITS suppresses commitment of offence or
attempts to falsified medicines, by tracking pharmaceuticals
in the supply chain individually. Thus, public health and
wealth are secured. In addition, recall of harmful drugs has
been achieved in very short time (more specifically in sec-
onds) comparing to older bureaucratic procedure, resulting
in prohibition of the drug. At the same time
˙
ITS provides
smooth communication among stakeholders by determining
the rules between transactions. Therefore,
˙
ITS provides the
occurrence of the ethical behaviours in business and sup-
ply chain. More specifically,
˙
ITS ensures the reliable sup-
ply of drugs to patients, prevents sale of spurious/falsely-
labelled/falsified/counterfeit drugs and barcode scams and
supports rational drug use, supplies data to control market.
1. INTRODUCTION
Product tracebility or, as it is more commonly called, Track
and Trace, is the ability to know the physical location of
an item at any time (Track) and the ability to know where
the item has been (Trace) in the past. [1] In this document
”Product Traceability” is synonymous with ”Track and
Trace”. The abbreviated equivalent for ”Pharmaceuticals
Track and Trace System” in the Turkish language is simply
known as
˙
ITS.
Beginning with Universal Declaration of Human Rights
[2], health innovation process is trying to reach the ideal.
Besides, providing public health services, which deal with
the diagnosis and treatment of disease, or the promotion,
maintenance and restoration of health, has been searching
for common solutions, for common problem of the whole
world, such as spurious, falsely-labeled, falsified or counter-
feit drugs.
Product traceability constitutes the foundation for a higher
level of patient safety by giving the ability to control drug
diversions and counterfeiting of pharmaceutical products.
These illegal practices pose a threat to the consumer/patient
by introducing potentially dangerous drugs into the market
[1] [3]. US and European government regulators are creating
opportunities for the adoption of new technologies in the
health care sector to improve patient safety [1] [4].
From the immemorial, man has been associated with greed
and ways to cut corners. Fake herbs such as Cinchona bark
existed in the 1600s, there was incidence of fake quinine in
the 1800s and counterfeit penicillin was found in post-war
Vienna in 1948. The World Health Organization (WHO)
first addressed this situation in 1958 and officially started
fighting counterfeit drugs in 1980 when the issue became a
major threat [5].
The ultimate solution for the drug counterfeit problem
should be the responsibility of everyone from consumers
to governments. Everyone needs to work together to try
to eliminate the problem completely. Just decreasing the
incidence rate is a good starting point, but the goal should
be total elimination: even a single case of a counterfeit drug
should not be acceptable [5].
We are aware of the fact that, in addition to the cost
in human lives, preventable medical errors cost money:
Pharmacoeconomics is defined as a social science con-
cerned with the description and analysis of the costs of
pharmaceutical products and services and their impact on
individuals, healthcare systems and society. Because phar-
macoeconomics is a social science substantially concerned
with the events in clinical practice, it overlaps with a branch
of medicine called outcomes research. Pharmacoeconomics
is that subset of economics that deals with pharmaceuticals
and includes economic outcomes [6].
As a result of studies, conducted for the benefit for public
health and public wealth, UK tried to use the track and
trace system. UK based company, Aegate, pilots a 3
month observational study involving 44 pharmacies and 5
pharmaceutical companies across England and Wales. The
pilot uses mass serialisation technologies; RFID, 1D and 2D
barcodes to authenticate at the point of dispensing, scanning
180,000 individual medicines in total [7].
Since then, many countries, that attempted to use a track and