© 2009 Palgrave Macmillan 0955–1662 Security Journal Vol. 22, 3, 205–218
www.palgrave-journals.com/sj/
Original Article
The effectiveness of women’s safety audits
Carolyn Whitzman
a,
*, Margaret Shaw
b
, Caroline Andrew
c
and Kathryn Travers
d
a
Faculty of Architecture, Building and Planning, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
E-mail: whitzman@unimelb.edu.au
b
International Centre for the Prevention of Crime, Montreal, Canada.
c
Faculty of Social Science, University of Ottawa, Canada.
d
Women in Cities International, Montreal, Canada.
*Corresponding author.
Abstract This paper discusses a methodological tool – the women’s safety audit – initially
developed in Canada, but which has been adapted and used in many regions of the world. The
women’s safety audit allows participants to identify safe and unsafe spaces and recommend
how the unsafe spaces can be improved. In doing so, the women’s safety audit privileges the
experience of women living in a neighbourhood as ‘experts’ in their own field. Based on inter-
views with six organizations in Europe, Africa and Asia and on an analysis of written sources,
the paper examines some of the applications, outcomes and challenges of this methodology. The
findings suggest that the audit is adaptable to local contexts, can be effective for bringing about
environment changes, empowering women and alerting the public and authorities to the shared
responsibility for ensuring the safety of women.
Security Journal (2009) 22, 205–218. doi:10.1057/sj.2009.1;
published online 18 May 2009
Keywords: women’s safety; safety audits; violence prevention; United Kingdom; India; Africa
Introduction
Women’s safety audits have been defined as ‘a process which brings individuals together to
walk through a physical environment, evaluate how safe it feels to them, identify ways
to make the space safer and organize to bring about these changes’ (WACAV (Women’s
Action Centre Against Violence Ottawa-Carleton), 1995, p. 1). Since it was developed
by Toronto’s Metro Action Committee on Public Violence Against Women and Children
(METRAC, 1989), the women’s safety audit tool has been disseminated to different regions
of the world. Women’s safety audits raise fascinating conceptual questions and introduce
very practical tools for interventions in communities. In this paper we evaluate the use that
has been made of women’s safety audits across the world. At the same time, we raise some
conceptual issues – Whose knowledge is used in building communities? Whose knowledge
is seen as legitimate? What kinds of knowledge can be understood and by whom? – as well
as describing the practical nature of women’s safety audits as a tool for improving urban
planning and management.
1