Page 1 of 4
Public Health, Ethical Vegetarianism, and the
Harms of the Animal Food Industry
William O Stephens*
Department of Philosophy, Creighton University, Omaha, USA
Review
Food is and always has been a serious issue for public health,
agriculture, the environment, and ethics. First, a brief sketch of the
history of the philosophical vegetarianism is offered. This overview
will allow several contemporary concerns about agricultural
systems, resultant environmental harms, threats to public health,
food insecurity, and dietary choices to be historically contextualized
and interrelated. The conceptual map presented more or less
chronologically here does not pretend to be comprehensive. But
despite its necessary incompleteness and unavoidable selectivity
the hope is that it may prove of modest use to inform food-secure
consumers who enjoy a range of healthy food options, desire to
safeguard public health, support sustainable agriculture, maintain
ecological integrity, and work for climate stability.
In the Western hemisphere, the idea of philosophical
vegetarianism has a history of nearly 1,000 years in ancient
Greece. The belief that it is wrong to eat animals was propounded
by many of the most eminent ancient philosophers: Pythagoras,
Empedocles, Theophrastus, who succeeded Aristotle as head
of the Lyceum, Plutarch, Plotinus, and Porphyry. Porphyry, a
prolific polymath, compiled a wide range of arguments against
vegetarianism, critiqued them in detail, and defended at length
his own Plotinian arguments for vegetarianism, in his work De
Abstinentia ab Esu Animalium [1]. In ancient Rome, Pythagoras’
arguments for philosophical vegetarianism won over the Stoic
philosopher, statesman, orator, and dramatist Seneca, who reported
improved health and vigor as benefits of abstaining from meat.
Seneca believed that Stoic philosophy, which grounds the virtues of
wisdom, justice, and temperance in pursuit of living in agreement
with nature, dictates simple, simply prepared, frugal meals of foods
that are close at hand. Thus, Seneca advocated moderate, unfussy
eating and condemned foods requiring great labor, expense, or
trouble. Seafood, imported foods, meat from hunted animals, and
exotic mushrooms he criticized as decadent luxuries.
The respected Roman Stoic teacher Musonius Rufus also
emphasized the virtues of simplicity and frugality in eating. He
argued that the proper diet consists of the least expensive and
most readily available foods: raw fruits in season, raw and cooked
vegetables, milk, cheese, honeycombs, and cooked grains. Like
Seneca, Musonius rejected meat as too crude for human beings
and more suitable for wild animals. Musonius concluded that
responsible people favor what is easy to obtain over what is difficult,
what involves no trouble over what does, and what is available over
what isn’t, because doing so promotes self-control and virtue of
character. For him, these values called for a lacto-vegetarian diet
*Corresponding author: William O Stephens, Department of Philosophy, Creighton
University, USA.
Received Date: June 28, 2019
Published Date: July 02, 2019
ISSN: 2687-8100 DOI: 10.33552/ABEB.2019.02.000529
Archives in
Biomedical Engineering & Biotechnology
Mini Review Copyright © All rights are reserved by William O Stephens
This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License ABEB.MS.ID.000529.
Abstract
In the West, the history of philosophical vegetarianism began in ancient Greece and Rome, not the 1970s. Yet as the global human population has
grown, so has the world’s population of domesticated livestock. The expanding industrialization of the animal food sector is guilty of various serious
environmental and societal harms, including climate change and public health threats. The meat industrial complex, perpetuated by the ideology of
carnism, is too inefficient, too damaging, and too costly to sustainably feed a growing human population. The virtuous choice is to replace meat, eggs,
and dairy products with plant-based foods.
Keywords: Vegetarianism; CAFO; Meat industrial complex; Carnism; GHG; 4Ns