54 Global Journal of Earth Science and Engineering, 2018, 5, 54-67
E-ISSN: 2409-5710/18 © 2018 Avanti Publishers
Methods of Determining Retardation Coefficients of Organic
Compounds in Aquifers
Munjed A. Maraqa
*
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, United Arab Emirates University, Al Ain, United Arab
Emirates
Abstract: Sorption is an important mechanism that affects the mobility of organic compounds in the subsurface
environment. Sorbed compounds move slower than that of groundwater, causing retardation in their movement.
Accurate determination of retardation coefficients (R) of organic compounds in aquifers is critical for understanding their
movement, fate, and remediation. Several methods, including predictive tools, laboratory experiments, and field
experiments have been utilized for determining sorption-related retardation. The objective of this paper was to review
and compare between the different methods used for the determination of R of organic compounds, with emphasis on
predictive- and laboratory-based approaches. Predictive tools are based on the use of quantitative structure-activity
relationships (QSARs). Laboratory methods utilize different types of reactors including batch, stirred-flow, circulation-
through-column, or miscible displacement through packed columns. In addition, data from the column method have been
analyzed in various ways to determine R. Discrepancies between results from different methods or from different
analysis approaches have been reported. This create uncertainty about the suitability of some of these methods or the
used analysis approaches. This paper highlights the possible causes for the observed discrepancy and establishes the
limitations and appropriateness of the used methods and analysis approaches.
Keywords: Batch method, Column method, Retardation factor, Sorption, Organic compounds, Sorption equilibrium
coefficient, Groundwater contamination.
1. INTRODUCTION
Groundwater accounts for approximately 35% of all
water withdrawals by humans. Thus, protecting
groundwater resources from anthropogenic
contamination is important especially in areas with
limited surface water resources, such as arid and semi-
arid countries. This has been emphasized by the World
Health Organization [1] as well. However, contaminants
such as synthetic organic compounds are still being
released into the subsurface water. The fate of organic
contaminants in the subsurface environment has
received a lot of attention in the last four decades due
to their impact on human health [2, 3].
Organic compounds could be ionic or nonionic,
aromatic or aliphatic. Owing to the presence of these
compounds in groundwater and their potential to reach
underlying aquifers, several studies focused on their
movement and methods of treatment. Attention was
given, for example, to chlorinated organic compounds
[4, 5], aromatic hydrocarbons [6, 7], polynuclear
aromatic hydrocarbons [8], polychlorinated biphenyls
[9], and pesticides [10]. In recent years, studies have
started covering emerging compounds such as
pharmaceuticals, hormones, and personal care
*Address correspondence to this author at the Department of Civil and
Environmental Engineering, United Arab Emirates University, Al Ain, United
Arab Emirates; Tel. +971 3 713 5157; Fax: +971 3 713 4997;
Email: m.maraqa@uaeu.ac.ae
products [11-14]. These contaminants are released in
the subsurface water through different sources. The
highest reported pollution source in the United States is
underground storage tanks [15]. Other sources include
leakage from oil pipelines [16], sewage pipelines [17],
septic systems [4, 18], leaching from landfills [19, 20],
irrigated lands [21], and livestock farming [22].
The mobility of dissolved organic compounds in
aquifers could be influenced by several transfer and
transform mechanisms. These compounds move within
groundwater through advection; a process that
depends on the hydraulic conductivity and the hydraulic
gradient of the aquifer. These compounds also
disperse during their transport due to molecular
diffusion and mechanical dispersion. The sum of
molecular diffusion and mechanical dispersion is
termed as hydrodynamic dispersion. Advection and
dispersion are transfer mechanisms that affect both
conservative and nonconservative compounds.
Additionally, organic compounds could be influenced
by reactive transfer mechanisms or could be subject to
transformation. Transform mechanisms cause
degradation of the compound either through a chemical
reaction (hydrolysis, oxidation-reduction, or
complexation) or through biological processes.
Reactive transfer mechanisms, however, do not alter
the structure of the compound, but affect its mobility in
the liquid phase by reducing its speed relative to that of
groundwater, causing compound retardation.