Communication
Wave-Mixed and Orbitally Shaken Single-Use
Photobioreactors for Diatom Algae Propagation
Nicolai Lehmann
1,
*, Heiko Rischer
2
, Dieter Eibl
1
, and Regine Eibl
1
DOI: 10.1002/cite.201200137
Although vertical column, flat-plate, tubular, bubble column and airlift photobioreactors are widely used for the cultivation
of diatoms, it has been shown that bubble-induced hydrodynamic stress created in these types of bioreactor can damage
cells. Therefore, three single-use surface-aerated bag bioreactors, known for their outstanding results in cultivating shear-
sensitive mammalian cells, were for the first time investigated for their suitability in growing the model microalgae Phaeo-
dactylum tricornutum. All of the systems, which were additionally aerated with CO
2
and equipped with illumination sys-
tems providing different light qualities, guaranteed a 22- to 43-fold increase in cell density within seven days, without any
addition of cell protection agents or changes in cell morphology. Maximum cell density and dry biomass were achieved in
the orbitally shaken 2D-bag by using cool-white fluorescent tubes.
Schlagwörter: Diatom, Growth characteristics, LED, Orbitally shaken, Phaeodactylum tricornutum, Single-use bioreactor,
Wave-mixed
Received: August 06, 2012; revised: September 02, 2012; accepted: September 28, 2012
1 Problem
Diatoms are one of the largest and most important groups
of microalgae [1, 2] and are regarded as a potential source of
high-value products such as polyunsaturated fatty acids, na-
tural colorants, biopolymers and therapeutic agents [1 – 5].
Controlled in vitro production processes using diatoms are
performed in photobioreactors such as vertical-column, flat-
plate, tubular, bubble column and airlift [6,7]. However, se-
veral authors reported that diatoms can be damaged by
shear stress induced by mixing and aeration [8, 9]. Inter-
estingly, it has been shown that Phaeodactylum tricornutum
is especially sensitive to aeration-induced hydrodynamic
stress [9, 10], arising from the bursting of small bubbles on
the medium surface of bubble column and airlift photobio-
reactors.
To date, the suitability of surface-aerated single-use bio-
reactors operating with a ready to use, pre-gamma radiated,
light-transmissive flexible plastic bag instead of a sterilized
glass vessel has not been described for P. tricornutum. Such
surface-aerated single-use bioreactors include wave-mixed
bioreactors and orbitally shaken systems [11, 12]. A key com-
ponent of both bioreactor types is the 2D- or 3D-cultivation
bag, which is either moved on a rocker or a shaker unit and
is fixed and shaped by a support container (collecting pan or
vessel) [12]. The medium containing the cells is efficiently
mixed by rocking or shaking the bag, which continuously
renews the medium surface and provides bubble-free sur-
face aeration. Power input and oxygen transfer in these sin-
gle-use bioreactors can be adjusted and controlled via
rocking- or shaking rate, rocking angle, shaker diameter, fil-
ling level and aeration rate [13, 14]. As described by Werner
et al. [15] wave-mixed and orbitally shaken systems are cha-
racterized by homogeneous energy dissipation. It is assu-
med that shear-sensitive cells tolerate this better and it
results in reduced cell damage. The phenomenon of homo-
geneous energy dissipation was already described for airlift
bioreactors in the late 1990s [16]. But thereby cell damage
from bubble aeration, extensive foaming and resultant flota-
tion can occur. In contrast, in wave-mixed and orbitally
shaken single-use bioreactors, shear stress from bubble
aeration is not a concern and it is even possible to perform
the cultivation without the addition of antifoam agents,
something which will simplify downstream processing of
diatom-based bioactive substances.
In the subsequently described growth experiments two
wave-mixed single-use bag photobioreactor prototypes and
one orbitally shaken single-use bag photobioreactor were
used. They are equipped with illumination systems provi-
ding differing light qualities: cool-white fluorescent tubes
(particularly strong at the blue and red ends of the light
spectrum), white LEDs, and white and red light LEDs. Pho-
ton flux densities of between 56 and 1712 lmol m
–2
s
–1
are
Chemie
Ingenieur
Technik
Chemie Ingenieur Technik 2013, 85, No. 1–2, 197–201 © 2013 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cit-journal.com
–
1
Nicolai Lehmann (nicolai.lehmann@zhaw.ch), Prof. Dr. Dieter
Eibl, Prof.Dr. Regine Eibl, Zurich University of Applied Sciences,
School of Life Sciences and Facility Management, Campus Grüen-
tal, 8820 Wädenswil, Switzerland;
2
Dr. Heiko Rischer, VTT Techni-
cal Research Centre of Finland, Tietotie 2, 02044 VTT, Finland.
Diatom 197