Learning Phonemes Without Minimal Pairs
Jessica Maye and LouAnn Gerken
University of Arizona
1. Introduction
The question addressed by this research is how humans acquire the
internalized, mental categories that reflect the phonemes
1
of their language. That
humans have such categories is evidenced by the fact that, for example, English
speakers immediately recognize pear and bear as being different words. This
immediate realization is independent of the fact that these two words have
different meanings, since English speakers will also report that nonsense words
like bove and pove are different words – despite the fact that neither word means
anything.
Phonemic categories, once acquired, have an influence on the perception of
speech sounds. Although adults can easily perceive acoustic distinctions that
differentiate the categories of their own language, they often have difficulty
perceiving non-native phoneme contrasts. For example, the English distinction
between /r/ and /l/ is difficult for native Japanese speakers to perceive
(Miyawaki et al. 1975), and the Hindi distinction between /t/ and /ţ/ (the latter
sound is retroflex, pronounced with the tongue curled backwards) is difficult for
native English speakers to perceive (Werker et al. 1981).
Infants are born with the ability to categorize speech sounds (Eimas et al.
1971), but these categories are initially universal, not based on the phonemes of
a particular language. For instance, Japanese-learning infants can initially
discriminate English /r/ and /l/ (Tsushima et al. 1994), and English-learning
infants can initially discriminate Hindi /t/ and /ţ/ (Werker et al. 1981). Over the
course of the first year of life, though, the infant gains experience with the native
language, and begins to only discriminate contrasts that represent a phonemic
distinction in the native language (Werker & Tees 1984). Through our research,
we would like to understand how these phoneme-related effects on speech
perception arise in the language learner.
2.0 The Acquisition of Phoneme Categories
Two types of hypotheses have been proposed to explain how these
phoneme-based categories are acquired, which can be roughly characterized as
minimal pair-based learning versus distribution-based learning. The minimal
pair-based hypothesis is that infants begin to attend to native language
phonemes when they learn that a phonetic distinction can differentiate the
© 2000 Jessica Maye and LouAnn Gerken. BUCLD 24 Proceedings, ed. S.
Catherine Howell et al., 522-533. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Press.