216
Artificial Neural Network in Applying Multi Attribute Control Chart for AR
Processes
Seyed Taghi Akhavan Niaki, Ph.D., Professor, Shirin Akbari Nasaji, BSc.
Department of Industrial Engineering
Sharif University of Technology (SUT)
Tehran, Iran 1458889694
e-mail: niaki@sharif.edu , shirin.akbari@gmail.com
Abstract— Quality characteristics are subject of both
manufacturing and service industries, which include not only
the variables but the attributes as well. In Quality Control
area substantial research has been done for Auto-correlated
variables; however, no attempt was done for Auto-correlated
attributes. Ignoring the autocorrelation structure in
constructing control charts cause the in-control run length to
decrease, and the false alarms to increase as such. In this
article we develop a new methodology based upon the
modified Elman neural network capabilities to overcome this
problem. Moreover, instead of back propagation, simulated
annealing is suggested as an alternative training technique
that is able to search globally and in order to generate random
AR vector we develop another artificial neural network based
on ARTA algorithm. We present a simulation experiments
and compare the performance of the proposed methodology
with the other control methods of multi-attribute processes.
The result of the simulation study is encouraging.
Keywords-component; Multi attribute control charts, neural
network, Autoregressive, ARTA
I. INTRODUCTION
Statistical control of many continuous processes deals
with data that exhibit some degree of autocorrelation. In a
control charting method development, the presence of
autocorrelation results in violating one of the key
assumptions, namely serial-sample independency. Violating
the independency assumption affects both the in and out-of-
control average run length (ARL) of the control charts and
makes them unreliable [3].
In general, there are two broad categories in statistical
control charting methods; variable and attribute control
charts [12]. The problem of monitoring auto-correlated
processes in variable control charts motivated many
researchers. Alwan [1] studied the effects of autocorrelation
on the performances of the Schewhart control charts and
found that there is an increased probability of both false and
genuine alarms when correlation is present. Kalgonda and
Kulkarni [9] proposed a new multivariate chart to detect and
diagnose mean shifts in presence of autocorrelation for
observations modeled by vector autoregressive of order one
(VAR(l)) process.
Many researchers have proposed several approaches to
take into account autocorrelation in the control charts. One
of the main approaches to deal with autocorrelation, which
was introduced for the first time by Alwan and Roberts [2],
978-1-4244-5586-7/10/$26.00 ©2010 IEEE
is to use a residuals control chart. Residuals are the
difference between the real and the forecasted values of the
mean vector of the process variables. They proved that when
they used an appropriate model to forecast the variables,
calculated residuals would be serially independent, so it was
possible to apply the common control charts for the
residuals.
Despite the fact that the multi-attribute monitoring has
many applications, almost all researchers have focused on
the first category of control charting and only a few methods
have been proposed to monitor multi-attribute processes.
Furthermore, in many instances where we may not need
exact measurements it is easy to collect correlated discrete-
type data. Patel [17] proposed a Hotelling-type χ2 chart to
monitor observations from multivariate Binomial or
multivariate Poisson distribution. In another research, Lu et
al. [11] addressed the statistical design of multi-attribute
control charts, where they proposed a multivariate np-chart
(Mnp chart) to develop Shewhart charts based on an X
statistic. Furthermore, they showed that this statistic reduced
type II errors better than individual np charts since the
correlation of attributes was taken into account. Jolayemi [8]
developed a model for an optimal design of multi-attribute
control charts for processes with multiple assignable causes.
In a more recent research in this area, Niaki and Abbasi [13]
based on a simple approach that almost eliminates the
existing correlations between the attributes, presented a
methodology to monitor multi-attribute processes, and
presented a rectangular region for the monitoring purposes.
Witnessing the increasing capability of artificial neural
networks (ANN) in modeling real systems, there is a great
interest in ANN for quality monitoring. Accordingly,
Larpkiattaworn [10] proposed a back propagation neural
network (BPNN) for bi-attribute Binomial process control
chart using the assumption of a positive correlation
providing a large enough sample size. In another research,
Niaki and Abbasi [14] employed a neural network to detect
and classify mean shifts in multi-attribute processes. They
applied the network to monitor not only the proportions of
several types of defects, but also the number of different
defects in a product online. Niaki and Davoodi [15]
considered a production process in which there were several
auto-correlated stages and in each stage, there were several
correlated quality variables to be monitored. In order to
control the resulting auto-correlated multivariate-multistage
process, they designed a single fully connected feed-forward
four layers ANN.
To the authors' best knowledge, a standard method for
constructing a multi-attribute control chart for auto-
Volume 5
Authorized licensed use limited to: Sharif University of Technology. Downloaded on June 06,2010 at 03:34:08 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.