Theor. Comput. Fluid Dyn.
DOI 10.1007/s00162-012-0261-2
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Bérengère Podvin · Patrick Le Quéré
Nonlinear dynamics between two differentially heated
vertical plates in the presence of stratification
Received: 17 October 2011 / Accepted: 21 February 2012
© Springer-Verlag 2012
Abstract We consider the numerical simulation of the flow between infinite, differentially heated vertical
plates with positive stratification. We use a two-dimensional Boussinesq approximation, with periodic bound-
ary conditions in the vertical direction. The relative stratification parameter γ = (
1
4
RaS)
1/4
, where Ra is
the Rayleigh number and S the adimensional stratification, is kept constant and equal to 8. The Prandtl num-
ber is 0.71. We derive a complex Ginzburg-Landau equation from the equations of motion. Coefficients are
computed analytically, but we find that the domain of validity of these coefficients is small and rely on the
numerical simulation to adjust the coefficients over a wider range of Rayleigh numbers. We show that the
Ginzburg-Landau equation is able to accurately predict the characteristics of the periodic solution at moderate
Rayleigh numbers. Above the primary bifurcation at Ra = 1.63 × 10
5
, the Ginzburg-Landau model is found
to be Benjamin-Feir unstable and to be characterized by modulated traveling waves and phase-defect chaos,
which is supported by evidence from the DNS. As the Rayleigh number is increased beyond Ra = 2.7 × 10
5
,
nonlinearities become strong and the flow is characterized by cnoidal waves.
Keywords Natural convection · Instabilities
1 Introduction
We consider the dynamics of a differentially heated vertical channel in the presence of stable stratification.
This configuration is of interest for several reasons. Firstly, differentially heated cavities are important from an
industrial point of view, from building applications to cooling of silicon chips. Secondly, the analogy between
rotating and free thermal convection flows [39] ensures that insight from the simulations studied here has
some relevance for rotating flows such as the Ekman layer, which is essential for meteorology and geophysical
studies.
A large number of studies focus on differentially heated cavities with isothermal walls, where the prescribed
temperature is constant. Elder’s experimental results [12, 13] indicated the presence of streamwise traveling
waves along the walls. Armfield and Patterson [2] showed that the development of the flow on an isolated
isothermal plate was similar to that of a cavity flow. Nagata and Busse [27] studied the three-dimensional
development of instabilities of a plane-parallel shear flow in the limit of zero Prandtl number. Chait and
Korpela [7] examined the stability of the secondary flow between isothermal plates and found that the flow
became rapidly three-dimensional. However, Henkes and Le Quéré [15] compared the transition to turbulence
for two-dimensional and three-dimensional cavities and found that three-dimensional effects only affected the
wall-heat transfer by about 15 %.
Communicated by Eldredge.
B. Podvin (B ) · P. Le Quéré
LIMSI-CNRS, Orsay, France
E-mail: podvin@limsi.fr