CHEMICAL ENGINEERING TRANSACTIONS
VOL. 35, 2013
A publication of
The Italian Association
of Chemical Engineering
www.aidic.it/cet
Guest Editors: Petar Varbanov, Jiří Klemeš, Panos Seferlis, Athanasios I. Papadopoulos, Spyros Voutetakis
Copyright © 2013, AIDIC Servizi S.r.l.,
ISBN 978-88-95608-26-6; ISSN 1974-9791
New Retrofit Approach for Optimisation and Modification
for a Crude Oil Distillation System
Dina Kamel
a,*
, Mamdouh Gadalla
a
, Fatma Ashour
b
a
Chemical Engineering Department, British University in Egypt, Cairo11837, Egypt
b
Chemical Engineering Department, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt
Dina.Ahmed@bue.edu.eg
Crude oil atmospheric distillation units consume substantial amounts of energy, as equivalent to a 2 % of
the total crude oil processed (Errico, 2009). An existing crude distillation unit is costly to modify due its
complex configuration and existing limitations of structure, space area, matches, bottlenecked
equipments, etc. Thus, a few new crude distillation units are built and most projects are directed to
revamping existing equipments. Modifying an existing plant is a tedious task, more complex than a new
process. While revamping, many parameters must be considered and structure limitations need to be met.
This paper develops a new revamping method based on rigorous simulation and optimisation procedures.
This method accounts for both the distillation column and the associated heat exchanger network at the
same time to maximise the use of existing equipments. The methodology considers process changes and
structural modifications together with the interactions between the existing distillation process and heat
recovery system. The new method is valid for multiple objective functions, i.e. saving energy, reducing
emissions, enhancing production capacity, and profit improvement.
The new presented methodology is applied to a local atmospheric plant for MIDOR, as an Egyptian
refinery case study. Many revamping options were obtained, including no structural modifications, simple
additional exchanger areas, and additional units or equipments.
1. Introduction
Crude distillation units (CDUs) are major energy-consuming units and therefore require extensive energy
management. There are many ways to increase energy efficiency, and heat exchanger network (HEN)
design and process heat integration are widely used methods. Heat transfer from hot products and pump-
around streams to the crude feed by the applications of HEN reduces the energy demands of both coolers
and furnaces. This reduction of energy demands diminishes the operating cost while increases the capital
cost for exchanger area installation, therefore, the retrofit design is more preferable than the grass-roots
design for oil refineries (Pejpichestakul, 2013). Standard objectives of revamping include increasing the
plant throughput, reducing the energy demands, utilising more efficiently the raw materials, reducing the
atmospheric emissions and waste generation. All these objectives preferably be fulfilled without modifying
much the physical constraints of the unit, such as column actual diameter, pump-arounds and side-
columns locations, exchanger matches and areas, maximum heat loads (fired heaters), etc. The
interactions between the existing distillation process and heat recovery system have a critical impact on
the revamping of the overall process. These interactions are the operating conditions of the distillation
column, including feed preheating temperature, steam flow rate, pump-around duties and flow rates and
reflux ratio, in addition to the existing exchanger matches and areas of the heat recovery system (Gadalla,
2003).Many researchers worked on revamping crude distillation units by sequential approaches i.e.
column revamping then HEN or vice versa, or in simultaneous approaches with targets of Pinch Analysis
(Gadalla et al., 2003). In these research works, existing heat exchanger networks were considered
through their targets only and not via their matches or physical constraints.
The main objective of this work is to develop a new methodology for revamping and simulation framework
for heat-integrated crude oil distillation systems. This approach is based on rigorous simulation and
1363
DOI: 10.3303/CET1335227
Please cite this article as: Kamel D., Gadalla M., Ashour F., 2013, New retrofit approach for optimisation and modification for a crude oil
distillation system, Chemical Engineering Transactions, 35, 1363-1368 DOI:10.3303/CET1335227